Andrew McIntyre

9.4

Serious wine this. Oaky with dark fruits and tobacco. Already balanced despite its youth. Definately not one of the lighter Brunellos. I loved this but drinkers seeking lithe, acidic elegance will be disappointed. — 25 days ago

GaryWEdwards

9.5

The fruit tumbled more as the decant wore on. Zero sediment upon decanting , this baby has legs for much longer haul. Beautiful balance and a gratifying long finish. I may come back in 5 years with a higher score. That's where this is headed. — 4 months ago

with Logan

Andy Stabile

9.2

This is really nice
Salt first. Big tart wine with some subtle subtle flavors. Some minty basil. Some spicy clove. Some funk. Tannins linger.
But not complex. A big enjoyable Tuscan.
I like it a lot…. But the world would probably even rate it higher than me. — 5 months ago

Bruce Leboff

9.0

Interesting. Elegant and classic Brunello nose - but 30 mins in…wondering if I haven’t waited a tad too long. Some fruit gone from the palate - good but maybe less than great. — 2 months ago

with Steven and David

Zack Hall

9.0

Definitely preferred the 2014, which I found to be a complete contender. This on the other hand did not seem in a good spot. — 4 months ago

Delectable Wine

Follow to learn about our favorite wines & people.

9.5

The 2016 Brunello di Montalcino Montosoli is quite mineral in the glass. Ashen stones, savory grilled herbs and smoked meats give way to woodland berries. This is dark and radiant, showing the classic racy fruit of the year, yet unbelievably soft and plaint, taking on a saline edginess toward the close. It finishes youthfully coy with dusty tannins, leaving just a touch of lingering licorice. The Montosoli is understated today, yet with a feminine beauty and inner sweetness that I find attractive. (Eric Guido, Vinous, December 2023)
— 5 months ago

Frank Artale

9.3

Bright red cherry earth forest floor roses graphite balsamic sage still with plenty of acid and tannins. Medium plus finish. Aromas and flavor pronounced. First tine I have had. Won't be the last. — 2 months ago

Pinotman /// Andreas

8.9

Quite brown already. Barky nose. Tons of tannins left. Seems overoaked and styled to me. I am glad i opened this up. Minty like a California Cab. More notes after this gets some air. Out of the gate not that impressive. Seems too old. — 3 months ago

Joe Weinberger

9.0

Disjointed upon opening. Lots of reduction that needed to blow off. Drinking much better after about hour being open. I don’t love this one as much as the ‘19 I had a couple times last year. — 5 months ago

Bob McDonald

9.5

Mid Ruby/garnet in colour. Earthy aromas - freshly tilled earth, red cherry, plum skins, menthol, leather and liquorice. The medium weight palate shows savoury cherry, spice and liquorice with fine persistent tannins. Drinking at its peak but will stay at this level for another 5 plus years. A brilliant match with pappardelle pasta, lamb, fresh basil and Parmesan (thanks Georgie). This wine was a treat, from an excellent year for Brunello - wish I had a few more bottles. — 5 months ago

with Hugh and Georgina