Tree Top Hill

Grosset

Polish Hill Clare Valley Riesling 2016

Fresh and pristine even at 10 years of age. Arguably Australia’s best Riesling - certainly in the top 3. Aromatics of lime juice with a tiny hint of TDN (paraffin in this case) and a hint of honey. Overall ultra pure with M+ intensity and a touch of peach on the palate. This could be confidentally cellared for another 5 years for added complexity. Dry Riesling doesn’t get much better than this. — 2 months ago

Tom, Tom and 17 others liked this
Ira Schwartz

Ira Schwartz Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Bob McDonald no gasoline on the nose? Have some older ones I need to pull.

Domaine Philippe Naddef

Vieilles Vignes Gevrey-Chambertin Pinot Noir 2022

Lyle Fass
9.6

Since Michel Naddef has taken over this estate is a top estate in the Gevrey/Fixin/Marsannay space. One thing I have learned is that these wines need serious air. So my note will evolve. Nose is minty with deep cherry fruit and some lovely intense minerals. But it’s not there yet. Not even close. Tree bark and some developing florals. Tremendous mint, Like a wild mint. Truly beguiling. Hint of meatiness as well. Wow the palate is truly gorgeous with such a meaty vibe and a dark vibe. Super elegant and crystalline pure but man it needs air but so similar to barrel. I will be back. Super sapid and deep with amazing sweet and ripe tannins. What a wine. Ah wow, now inner mouth aromas and elite finesse. But still tight. I think it will be better tomorrow like the Fixin and Marsannay. Dark flowers on the nose. So compelling. — 2 years ago

Daniel, Ray and 13 others liked this

Domaine Rémi Jobard

Les Narvaux Meursault Chardonnay 2018

A Blue Hill purchase near the top end of their inventory, this well balanced chardonnay didn't disappoint and is very much worth finding again. — 4 years ago

Enderle & Moll

Liaison Pinot Noir 2019

Tasting E&M since 2009 & visited a couple of times. 10 years later they are still at the top.
Challenging to taste and evaluate. This wine needs hours/days of air. Classic E&M perfume,
red currants, pine tree sap, white pepper on the nose. Looks like a light weight- Well? Underripe strawberries, later dark 🍒 , crushed marble, hint bitter, orange zest, prune skins, My suggestion pop drink for hours and listen to Vivaldi’s Spring Concerto in E-Minor - it is that good.
— 5 years ago

Jae, Lyle and 12 others liked this
Pinotman /// Andreas

Pinotman /// Andreas

Sorry was traveling - 2019 - Boy hard to say. I looked back at my notes and other bottles from E&M from the same vintage. Given that 2019 was a special vintage. I am leaning towards 2019. This has also to do with the fact that there was some VA in the 18 at first. Overall if one is interested in a Pinot which carries interest this is the best option at this price point. Definitely would give it some air.
Ely Cohn

Ely Cohn Premium Badge

19 it is!!
Ely Cohn

Ely Cohn Premium Badge

Thanks Andreas!

Hill Top Berry Farm & Winery

Virigina Peach

It’s peach and it’s sangria.... not sure there is much else to say. If you like peach and you like sangria you’ll like this. — 6 years ago

Kathryn P
with Kathryn

Cherry Tree Hill

Southern Highlands Riesling 2008

Clear, deep gold colour. Clean, pronounced mineral (petrol) and citrus aromas. Dry with high acidity. Medium bodied with pronounced butter, lemon and lime flavours. A long finish. An outstanding wine. — 7 years ago

Michele Walker
with Michele

Bell Hill Vineyards

Old Weka Pass Road Pinot Noir 2016

Pale Ruby. Some clove and tarry nuances on the nose. The pale colour belies the M+ Intensity. Very Burgundian in aroma, structure and palate. Even better on the 2nd night. The 2nd wine of Bell Hill made from younger vines from the top Cuvée. Very impressive. Only 1897 bottles made from Canterbury NZ and difficult to source even in Australia. — 7 years ago

Severn, Shawn and 12 others liked this

Chappellet

Pritchard Hill Estate Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2015

From magnum. Partially poured into a decanter and enjoyed over the course of a couple days. Best on Day 2. The 2015 Pritchard Hill pours a deep ruby/purple with an opaque core; medium+ viscosity with moderate staining of the tears. On the nose, the wine is developing and richly fruited with powerful, heady notes of cassis, blackberries, plum, purple flowers, tobacco, cocoa, some star anise and fine warm spices. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium+ tannin and medium+ acid. Confirming the notes from the nose. The finish is long and the texture is luxurious. Classic Pritchard Hill character and surely a candidate for top vineyard status if the US were to ever adopt a classification status. There’s a long future here, especially in this larger format. Drink now with patience through 2055. — 3 months ago

Juan, Somm and 11 others liked this
Jay Kline

Jay Kline Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Hard to say. The large format can skew things. I bet the 750’s are bangin
Scott@Mister A’s-San Diego

Scott@Mister A’s-San Diego Premium Badge

Nice but I'll always opt for the "Signature" offering for the price. Have tasted a decade's worth+ of the Pritchard Hill vehicle. A bit too plushy for me but the Signature is Baby Bear old school just right.
Jay Kline

Jay Kline Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Scott@Mister A’s-San Diego The Signature is great and most of the fruit is coming from Pritchard Hill anyway.

Realm Cellars

Farella Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2021

Somm David T
9.3

This one is a 93+ at this stage with room for improvements with some more age.

The Farella showed a more savory character than the rest. It’s body thicker than the others. Ruby; blackberries, black plum, black raspberries & raspberries. Herbaceous notes, soft minerality-rock powder, limestone, volcanics and just drying top soil, dry tobacco, sandalwood, perfectly executed baking spices, dark spice, vanillin, withering dark, red, blue and violets, nice round acidity, nice tension, structure, well knitted & balanced structure with an excellent full minute finish.

Pano photo of Pritchard Hill from the estate (what a stunning view), barrel room, the estates wine collection; which given the excellent producers in it (bottles of Petrus just one of very expensive producers), I’d be a little earthquake nervous & lay some thin wire over the bottles to hold them in place and their tank room.
— 3 years ago

Bob, Joshua and 10 others liked this

Wendouree

Shiraz 2011

In the Wendouree hierarchy of Cuvées the straight Shiraz is generally considered the premium with some of the vines dating back to the 1880s in age. Aromas of blackberry and aniseed with touches of mint. Not too much of the trademark Menthol/Eucalyptus found in most Wendouree Reds. Palate is a mixture of black and red fruits with a savouriness - earthy iron notes. 2011 was not a good vintage in South Australia as vintage conditions were very wet. I would normally not approach Wendouree reds under 15 years of age but because of the vintage I decided to open this. It still has another 10 years of life in front of it. The old vine material proves its worth even in poor vintages. Wendouree Shiraz is in the top Langtons Classification of Exceptional along with Grange and Hill of Grace. — 5 years ago

Billy, ESF and 16 others liked this

The Standish Wine Company

Single Vineyard Shiraz 2003

Somm David T
9.5

So, many of you have not had the pleasure of having Dan’s wines. It is largely due to the fact he doesn’t have a US importer. He sells all his mid production level wines through his mailing list. That makes importing from his mailing list as restrictive as the import fees. They are equal to the price of the wines you order. Not something you’ll do. I didn’t. You need to find his wines on the secondary market to be cost effective.

We had the privilege of visiting his Cellar Door in the Spring of 2017. What a fantastic visit and walk of his Estate with him. The age of his Estate vines are 100 plus years old and their yield is less than a ton per acre which, does not make for a lot of wine but, instead a very concentrated wine.

Dan traveled to and worked in many of the key wine regions before settling in as Torbreck’s Winemaker and then marching to his own drum doing his own thing as “The Standish”, his way. No compromises.

The first thing you need to know about Dan’s wines is you can drink them early but, that would be a huge mistake. This 03 is sensational now but, is worthy of more cellaring. It has 10-20 years of life ahead of it...proper storage of course.

This is a second night wine for us and it is still big.

The nose reveals smokey; blackberries, black raspberries, black plum skin, black cherries, blueberries, mulberries/boysenberries, baked/poached strawberries & some raspberries, sweet tarriness, dark berry cola, black pepper, steeped tea, eucalyptus, mint, tree bark with sap, herbaceous, dry crushed rocks, nutmeg, clove, cinnamon, vanilla, moist, forest floor with dry leaves with withering; dark, red, purple flowers framed in violets & strong lavender.

The body is full, round, lush & ruby. The tannins are still big, round, tarry & meaty. The structure, tension, length & balance are just there & yet still not there. It is still a monster on day two. Smokey; blackberries, black raspberries, black plum skin, black cherries, blueberries, mulberries/boysenberries, baked/poached strawberries & some raspberries, sweet tarriness, grilled meats, dark berry cola, black pepper, steeped tea, eucalyptus, mint, tree bark with sap, herbaceous-sage & rosemary, used charcoal, graphite, dark spice with palate heat, burned ambers, incense, rubber toy, dry crushed rocks, moist clay & top soil, dry stone, nutmeg, clove, cinnamon, vanilla, moist, forest floor with dry leaves with withering; dark, red, purple flowers framed in violets & strong lavender. The acidity is round and a rushing river. The extremely long finish is, big, round, elegant, floral, well balanced, runs juicy to dry with persistence for days falling onto earthiness & dark spice on the long set.

Photos of, a plaque that hangs above my kitchen sink that speaks to me always, Dan Standish, his Cellar Door and surrounding buildings.
— 6 years ago

Eric, Shay and 23 others liked this
Paul T, Missing My Beautiful Wife 24/7

Paul T, Missing My Beautiful Wife 24/7

3 years ago you gave it an 98, is it on the down slide now?
Somm David T

Somm David T Influencer Badge

I did. I also gave it a 96 before that. Different bottle, all different sources.
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

I had a couple bottles of the 2002 last year. My first experience with his wines. Great stuff.

Peter Michael Winery

'La Carrière' Knights Valley Chardonnay 2013

A very nice bottle of wine. I would say this one is drinking the way it was intended to drink. Ready to go. Full throttle for a Chardonnay. Nose of dried herbs, kettle corn, youthful fruit, minerals. Entry a lot of peach, guava, popcorn kernel. Lots of stone ground fruit, dried herbs, dense. Powerful. I don't think this one could drink any better than it is now. Opened to thank a friend for serving an excellent lineup of Peter Michael and Colgin four days before! This one is at the top of the hill right now. — 7 years ago

Dan Fitzgerald
with Dan
Shay, Serge and 20 others liked this

Holly's Hill

Hill Top El Dorado Syrah 2012

Dark and purply. Aroma is saucy and fruity. With a streak of black cherry. Flavor is amazing. Licorice and blackberry. Fine wine with style. — 9 years ago

Philip Togni Vineyard

Spring Mountain Cabernet Sauvignon 2007

Somm David T
9.6

This is a producer that should be more revered than it is. His 90’s were amongst my favorite Napa Cabernets. Especially, the 94, which is exceptional and I’ve had on 3-4 occasions.

2007 is a grand vintage but this one needs more cellaring. It is still in its adolescence. I would like to try this in another 8-10 yrs. Don’t get me wrong, this drinks nicely now but it’s best is still ahead.

I coravined & decanted this in a big Bordeaux glass for an hour and it is still a 1/2 monster.

The nose shows; dark currents/cassis, blackberries, black plum w/ skin, very black cherries, black raspberries, poached/slightly baked strawberries with understated raspberries in the glass edges, dark, rich earth with dry leaves, steeped fruit tea, mocha powder, caramel, chocolate baking bar, understated baking spices-cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, vanillin, both black & red licorice/cola, moist herbs, tree sap, limestone, dry top soils-river stone and beautiful, withering/candied dark & red florals framed in candied violets.

The M+ tannins are round, velvety, dusty and still meaty. Dark currents/cassis, blackberries, black plum w/ skin, very black cherries, black raspberries, poached/slightly baked strawberries, liqueur cherries with understated, hovering raspberries. Dark, rich earth with dry leaves, steeped fruit tea, mocha powder, caramel, chocolate baking bar, understated baking spices-cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, vanillin, both black & red licorice/cola, moist herbs, tree sap, soft, moist cigar box, leather, anise, rounded very dark spices, moist clays, limestone, dry top soils-river stone and beautiful, withering/candied dark & red florals framed in candied violets, very round, pleasant acidity with balance for days, still pronounced structure/tension, great length and a smartly, polished, ruby two-minute finish that long sets on on deep, dark spice, earthiness & ruby, dark currents.

Right now a Filet steak, not a fatty steak, Ribeye or Ribcap.

Still so youthful! Add a point or two in 7-10 yrs. .

Philip is in his 90’s and still involved in the winemaking. He walks the property daily.
— 7 months ago

Jeroen, Scott@Mister and 7 others liked this
Jeroen Koenen

Jeroen Koenen

A personal favorite! The 1997 iteration of this wine converted me, being a classic Bordeauxphile, into American wines some 20 years ago. Thank you for that, Mr. Togni.

Vine Hill Ranch

Oakville Cabernet Sauvignon 2008

I really enjoy FP wines. This bottle has aged very nicely not necessarily elegant but not an over the top bruiser — 3 years ago

Billy and Ron liked this

Domaine Jean-Louis Chave

J.L. Chave Sélection Hermitage Blanche Marsanne Roussanne 2018

Fantastic Hermitage from Chave’s negociant business, essentially made with the fruit that doesn't end up in the 'Domaine' Hermitage Blanc (the $300 one). Blend of Marsanne and Roussanne primarily sourced from the Maison Blanche, a lieu-dit at the top of the Hermitage hill, as well as some fruit from l’Ermite and Peleàt. Fermented and aged in barriques for 18-24 months. Beautiful nose. White fruit, exotic, floral notes. Full-bodied, honeyed, rich. Great texture. Extraordinary — 4 years ago

Pelican Ranch

Meadowridge Vinyard Pinot Noir 2009

Somm David T
8.9

A local producers wine we bought at a tasting we literally ran into quite awhile ago. I forgot about it. Left it in improper storage and thought about just chucking it. Then, I said, ah try it. Surprisingly still good. Might help it really doesn’t get very hot here often. As well, it had a screw top. If anyone doesn’t think screw top wines don’t age more slowly, this wine is here to say you’re incorrect in that thinking. In fact, this 09 still has 3-5 years of life in it despite its unconventional storage.

It’s dark, ripe, lush & juicy fruits of; blackberries, black raspberries, black cherries, both plums, some raspberries & hints of blueberries. Tree sap with bark, dark, sweet tarriness, cinnamon stick, dark spices with some heat, clove nutmeg, vanilla, forest floor, volcanics, limestone, dry crushed rocks, dry tobacco, anise, mint, herbal notes, dark, red and purple florals. Acidity is pleasant. The finish is steady, nicely balanced fruit & earth and falls into minerals & spice as it sets.

For a Pinot, it is showing a pronounced amount of tannins and showed tannin sludge in the neck while decanting.

@Delectable this is from Corralitos in the Southern Santa Cruz Mountains not the Santa Rita Hills.
— 6 years ago

Eric, Dawn and 19 others liked this
Paul T, Missing My Beautiful Wife 24/7

Paul T, Missing My Beautiful Wife 24/7

I love finding a bottle under the couch after 10 years 👍🏼
Somm David T

Somm David T Influencer Badge

@Paul T- Huntington Beach Actually, it was in the back of my unmatched sock drawer.

Domaine Henri Boillot

Bourgogne Chardonnay 2018

Somm David T
9.0

This is hard to beat at $25.

White cheese starter.

Copying over & updating earlier notes...

The nose reveals; waxy, sweet & sour lemons, the light, good/softer aspects of lemon pledge, lime zest, green & golden apple, overripe pineapple, honeysuckle, apricots, white peach, orange rind, grapefruit w/ pith, tree bark, flintiness, notes of roasted caramel, vanillin, beautifully, elegant, grey volcanics, salty, powdery, even slightly floral chalkiness, white to lightly brown spices, sea spray, oyster notes, limestone/sandstone, fruit blossoms, yellow lilies framed in a field of spring flowers.

The body is thick, rich, lush and nicely rounded. If you like viscosity, no issues here. It guides over the palate presenting no mouth arguments. Waxy, sweet & sour lemons, the light, good/softer notes of lemon pledge, green & some golden apple with skin, lime zest, overripe pineapple, honeysuckle, apricots, white peach, orange rind, tropicals green melon, tree bark, notes of roasted caramel, beautifully, elegant, grey volcanics, salty, powdery, even slightly floral chalkiness, white to lightly brown spices with some medium palate heat, sea spray, oyster notes, sulfur/flintiness, limestone/sandstone, fruit blossoms, yellow lilies framed in a field of spring flowers. The acidity is near dead on...like a gentle cool stream. The long finish is, gorgeous & sexy, elegant, rich, good balance all around and persists gently for minutes.

Just gets better & better as it warms & opens up in the glass. This Bourgogne will add another point or two when I open my next bottle in 2-3 years. Except now, I own a bunch more of this 2018. Have some to enjoy early.

Excellent with our soft, white cheese...Jasper Hill Farms-Harbison. If you can find this cheese, it gets one of my highest recommendations. Bought it at Whole Foods but, you can always check JasperHillFarms.com if N/A where you shop.

Photos of; Masion Henri Boillot, Owner/Winemaker Henri Boillot, tasting room that looks into the barrel room and his Bonnes Mares Vineyard.
— 7 years ago

Severn, Aravind and 23 others liked this

Château Cos d'Estournel

Les Pagodes de Cos Saint-Estéphe Red Bordeaux Blend 2005

Somm David T
9.1

This is the 2nd wine of Cos d'Estournel.

The nose reveals; blackberries, dark cherry pie, poached strawberries, plum, black raspberries, blueberries, well extracted pomegranate, burnt ambers, touch of incense, dark, rich, earth, limestone minerals, tree sap, black tea, used leather, pipe tobacco, dark asian spices, clove, nutmeg, very light cinnamon & vanilla, mint notes, wood shavings, herbaceous notes, dry brush, dry stone with dark fresh & withering flowers, violets and hints of lavender.

The body is near full, round and lush. The tannins are well resolved but still have baby teeth with some dark, sticky tarriness. The structure, tension are still fairly big. The length and balance are starting to round into top form. For a 2nd wine from a very good vintage, there is a depth that missing. While this wine still has a decade of life left in it, I’m not sure it gets a whole lot better. It’s more a distant relative in 05 than a baby brother to its big brother. Maybe, the earth and fruit get into better balance? Oddly, I think it’s the fruit that is holding their 2nd wine back a bit, which is odd for such a good vintage & good producer of Bordeaux. Mostly ripe; blackberries, dark cherry pie, poached strawberries, plum, black raspberries, boysenberries, blueberries & well extracted pomegranate. Burnt ambers, touch of incense, dark, rich, earth, limestone minerals, tree sap, black tea, used leather, pipe tobacco, darker asian spices with palate heat, clove, nutmeg, very light cinnamon & vanilla, heavier mint notes, dark chocolate, used expresso grounds, cedar plank, graphite, more pronounced herbaceousness, dry brush, dry clay, dry crushed rocks, dry stone with dark fresh & withering flowers, blue flowers, violets and hints of lavender. The acidy is round and nice. Perhaps, a shade off for the vintage. The finish is ripe, heavier on the earth than fruit leaving a significant palate dryness on the long set that persists for minutes.

Photos of; Chateau Cos d'Estournel, which sits just inside Saint-Estèphe bordering Pauillac, the back patio of Cos d'Estournel, library wines and sometimes tasting lounge and their spectacular barrel room.
— 8 years ago

Ryan, Shay and 33 others liked this
leon egozi

leon egozi

I can get an appointment but they are charging almost 1600 euros for up to 6 guests😱
Somm David T

Somm David T Influencer Badge

@leon egozi I guess they are tired of watching Napa make it rain 💴 with their crazy tasting fees and feel they need more money 💴 to pay for that pricey remodel they did a few years back. They have also hit a nice run of high RP scores with their first wine and think they’ve earned it. 🤷‍♂️ Crazy! Happy to be a professional in this case.
leon egozi

leon egozi

Yep so true