Victor Chang

9.5

Licorice and cookie spice on the nose. Prominent fruit up front, blackberry, with a long finish. Would imagine that this should age well, if you have the patience and discipline. — 8 years ago

Jon Fine

9.2

layered, smart, ridiculously fun and tasty. — 9 years ago

David Kline

9.3

Pinecones and orange blossoms. Pineapple cake and dried apricots fill your nostrils. Lemon-orange, maple, sweet corn, creamy grapefruit, pine nuts and lemon cookie coalesque and then a resinous pine in burlap emerges triumphant in the face of the tropical monsoon. It carries on like pine tar on a baseball bat. Home run! — 9 years ago

with Courtney

Benjamin Gaeddert

9.1

Quite light for Côte-Rôtie. Smart and sophisticated with just enough red fruit to play along with the savory, umami character. Medium tannins and acidity and with plenty of remaining longevity. — 10 years ago

David Kline

9.3

This thing is like a merengue cookie after you get through the citrus zest and gum arabic candy crust. There is a tangerine characteristic, that turns into tangerine pith, and has a powdered sugar millisecond before becoming bony and rich. This thick little lady is bumping in every respect! — 10 years ago

with Courtney

Alison

9.0

Paired with Girl Scout cookie: Thanks-a-lot — 10 years ago

Peter Scudamore-Smith MW

9.4

Smart from age in bottle under screw; Clare Valley, SA — 10 years ago

Davis Smith

Sommelier Acquerello

9.3

And the opposite side of the spectrum. Toasty, nougat, chocolate chip cookie dough — 11 years ago

Alexa Rose

9.2

Like eating sugar cookie dough as a kid. — 12 years ago

with Glen

Giampiero Nadali

Wine Blogger Aristide

9.1

Smart interpretation of a very popular grape, Schiava or Vernatsch. Transparent red color, wide sensations at taste of red fruits, salty acidity, and the long and funny to drink! — 12 years ago

Joe Lucca

9.2

Tightly wound. Needs time. Oatmeal raisin cookie and doughnut on the nose. Crushed rocks, clay, deep red fruit. Nice spice at the end. — 8 years ago

with Frank, Kevin and 3 others

I

9.2

Nice, fuerte in a goodish way. Would do it again, smart — 9 years ago

Dongming Yin

8.9

blackberry and apple ...nonono this is not a combination of two smart phones... — 9 years ago

JL

8.9

Scharffenberger Brut, Rose, Mendocino County. Well balance fruits, acidity, fine finish. Had this is Café Epi, Palo Alto , tasted with chocolate chip cookie. Yum! — 10 years ago

Dmitri

9.0

Violets, cherries, strawberries, ginger bread cookie. Palate is silky, with medium acids, soft fruit, medium tannins. Quite nice young. — 10 years ago

Ben Walker / Caravin

8.9

100 year old vines, languedoc Carignan. Big tanins, big body. Lavender & Leather. Belinda demands it to be decanted- smart move. Nice sleep-wine from big John. — 10 years ago

Jeroen Koenen

9.3

Moody copper gold in color. Wonderfully mature, botrytis infused, sugar-coated pecans, salty caramel, cookie dough, dried guava, cappuccino cream, cured ham. Did I say it's very complex!? Really love the balance and mixture of full-throttle sweetness and mouthwatering savoury, hearty elements. Beautiful wine to sip and contemplate on this perfect Indian-Summer-Sunday.... — 11 years ago

Karina Cisneros

9.7

Yeah buddddy! Deep dark cherry pie with a sugar cookie crust. Bright red cherry on the palate. Delish!!!!!! Definitely revisit! — 11 years ago

Willem Booij

9.6

Oeff, thick, fat and powerful. This is a baby but good looking and very smart for his age. Sexy, silky stuff in a boxing clove — 11 years ago

Giampiero Nadali

Wine Blogger Aristide

9.0

In Porrera, the freshest part of Priorat, this is a very young winery, with smart ideas about wine, architecture and design. Very elegant, smooth, long finish. — 12 years ago

Paul DeBono

9.0

Pretty darn good. Not sure it's going to pair well with a cookie making night, but it has that "it's Friday" depth you look for when kicking off the weekend. — 8 years ago

Martin G Rivard

9.3

@David A Lentine @Gina Sabean @Christine You know that you are drinking GREAT wines when you can say that a Realm Beckstoffer To Kalon came in last. I love this producer beyond measure!! Every wine they make is a hit. Everyone tonight agreed that drank by itself it would have been amazing. However, it still needs a few years to open up and spread its wings!! All of my bottles were decanted for 8 hours today, I began formulating thus rodeo of a lineup around 11am. The Realm had huge dark fruit but too many rough edges in comparison to the others. In all honesty, these are so good that we are splitting hairs but alas they must be ranked and that is how the Cookie Crumbled this evening. — 9 years ago

with Christine and Gina

Ned Gray Creed

9.2

Habit tasting. Dry farmed! Awesome. Gruner! Awesome. Jeff Fischer. Smart man. — 9 years ago

Paul Costigan

Founder Courtier Wines

9.4

1991: Trusting the makeshift neck tag. Reticent nose, yet full delivery on palate. Book smart Cote Rotie, with everything you'd expect present. The youngster of the night, yet in welcome company. No hurry to drink, will continue to develop. — 10 years ago

Riccardo L.

9.0

Nicely balanced and deep. Licorice on the finish with smart tannins. A little loopy throughout... likely thanks to the Syrah content. Nice little super tuscan! — 10 years ago

Robbie P

9.2

Tastes great with a Linzer torte cookie. I — 10 years ago

Linda Hawk

9.6

Floral, smooth — 11 years ago

JuliAnn Sklow

9.7

Perfect Christmas cookie baking wine... — 11 years ago

Carissa Bryant

9.8

Very smooth. Sweet! Silky. — 12 years ago

Isabel Hall

9.0

Smart cookie! — 12 years ago