Carl Fischer

Wine lover in NYC, particularly obsessed with CA wines. Founding member, Wine Nerd Herd.

968 wines • 231 followers • 148 following

Morgado

Sugarloaf Mountain Merlot Cabernet Franc 2016

Carl Fischer

9.3

Carl had this 9 months ago

with Mike, Shawn and 5 others

Mike, Eric and 53 others liked this

Bryan Kesting

@Shay A : thank you for sharing these with me on day 2!

Texturé

Anderson Valley Pinot Noir 2014

Carl Fischer

9.2

Carl had this a year ago

with Ron, Shawn and 6 others

Shawn, David and 80 others liked this

Bryan Kesting

@Shay A : never had wines from Texture.

Shay A

@Bryan Kesting : I think the chard is up your alley. Very Ceritas like.

Mike R

Again agree Shay - prefect notes - this wine needs 2 hours after opening

9.3

Levy & McClellan

Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2004

Carl Fischer

9.5

Carl had this a year ago

with Joe, Ron and 2 others

Mike, David and 100 others liked this

David L

04’ I’ve enjoyed a few times. Once with you. @Mike R

Sharon B

Fun!

John A

Really nice pull. Glad you are still sharing these moments

Morgado

Steiner Vineyard Chardonnay 2016

Carl Fischer

9.3

Carl had this 9 months ago

with Eric, Ron and 6 others

Eric, Ron and 57 others liked this

Eric L.

Your note captures it pretty well, Shay. 👍

Bryan Kesting

@Shay A : Thanks for sharing this one as well. Your notes are right on.

Bill Bender

Agree with @Eric LaMasters your notes 📝 are on point. I was impressed with this wine.

Texturé

Lucky Well Vineyard Chardonnay 2016

Carl Fischer

9.4

Carl had this a year ago

with Joe, Eric and 6 others

Eric, Bill and 53 others liked this

Mike R

Agree with my friend @Shay A

9.4

Bill Bender

I agree to agree with those who agree with each other

Mike R

Haha @Bill Bender how can you not agree with those that agree with other

Aston Estate

Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 2015

Carl Fischer

9.4

Carl had this a year ago

with Anne-marie, Eric and 2 others

Shay, Paul and 68 others liked this

Ron R

@Maciej Kurka, thanks for the feedback. You’re correct about the dog design.

Bill Bender

🤜🏼🤛🏾 eternally grateful for your friendship @Ron R

Ron R

@Bill Bender, ditto!!!

Brilliant Mistake Wines

Napa Valley Sauvignon Blanc 2018

Carl Fischer

9.2

Carl had this 10 months ago

with Anne-marie, Eric and 4 others

Severn, Eric and 63 others liked this

Ron R

@Mike R, I made a mistake with my vintage. I also had the 2018! 🙂

Sharon B

Nice picture!

Mike R

I thought so lol

9.3

Ulysse Collin

Les Maillons Rosé de Saignee Extra Brut Champagne Pinot Noir

Carl Fischer

9.6

Carl had this 10 months ago

with Joe, Shawn and 4 others

David, Shawn and 73 others liked this

Ron R

Yes, gents. This was special on another level. The visual shapes your expectations, and in no way did the visual flatter to deceive. Thanks again, @Shawn R and Jennifer!

Hugh O'Riordan

The wine glasses ! You are living large

Ron R

Yes,@Hugh O'Riordan. Good call.

Château Cos d'Estournel

Saint-Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend 2002

Carl Fischer

9.5

Carl had this a year ago

with Eric, Shawn and 3 others

Deborah, Eric and 147 others liked this

Dawn E.

@Ron R sounds fabulous! Cheers! 🍷

Ron R

Thanks guys n gals. I’m thrilled at how well this has evolved. Particularly as the 02 vintage was pas bon!

Mike R

Oh my friend - glass please you lucky man

Petaluma

Tiers Chardonnay 2002

Carl Fischer

9.5

Carl had this a year ago

with Anne-marie, Eric and 2 others

Dick, Severn and 64 others liked this

Ron R

Thanks, @John Adams. I’m trying to copy my artsy fartsy wife 😀

Mario Vaillancourt

Very nice pic and the wine and food look delicious

Ron R

Thanks, @Mario Vaillancourt. Both food and wine were excellent 😊