Matthew Cohen

9.3

10% new oak

Nose: plummy dusty.

Palate: darker fruit. More pommard-like. But bright. Very good balance. Hint of balancing bitterness. Very lithe

288/360. Jd 93 — 13 days ago

Jerry Raphael

8.9

Not as intense as the Roar but very good. Some cola, dark fruits and more. — 5 months ago

Eric Urbani

9.3

Wes Hagen, 20 year veteran wine maker at Clos Pepe Vineyard, joined our group and gave us a master class in Santa Barbara pinot noir. We tried 11 PNs from 2004-2010, made by Loring, AP Vin, Sandler, Siduri, and Brewer-Clifton. This AP Vin was my #2 although the group rates it closer to the middle of the pack. No longer producing unfortunately… — a year ago

Matthew Cohen

9.1

Loring boekenoogen pinot noir.

Nose: mint: Lovely.

Palate: young. Early season cherry. Lovely precise cherry fruit.

288/360 — 13 days ago

Jerry Raphael

9.0

Drinking great — 5 months ago

Eric Urbani

9.2

Oh yes. The 2018! — 9 months ago

Hayden Hamilton

9.1

Loved the ‘09 and a fan of Shea. This was near the best of both. Bright red fruit. No tannin. Nothing not to like. Would buy a case of it if I could find it. — 2 years ago

Matthew Cohen

9.0

No new oak. Most Kessler hawk

Nose: white flowers. Pear.

Palate: delicious. Pear. Clean. No oak taste.

216/264

13.5% — 13 days ago

Matthew Cohen

9.1

Nose: interesting white flowers. Elegant honeysuckle.

Palate: elegant honey. Very delicious. A touch of rs but not too much.

216/264 — 13 days ago

Michael Walker

9.8

Didn’t know Kistler was in the Pinot business until this showed up from WB…and while a very good one, not up to Kistler’s level in Chardonnay…very nicely fruit forward, but a little too sparkly at the front and a little too wooden at the back. Solid but not exceptional….falls short of Loring & Testarrossa — a year ago