Ely Cohn

9.2

Pings your nostrils with sequence of subtle vibrations at hummingbird frequency. Lime, orange blossom, burnt match. Then a slow slip into my absolute favorite honeyed dimension. I love when honey shows up - it's one of my favorite notes in wine. Here it changes the direction from steely stern face to a textured viscous warm smirk. — 2 years ago

Raun Kupiec

8.9

Very nicely balanced combination of acidity and fruit. — 5 years ago

with Barbara

Samantha Potter

9.1

Now that’s a #Spätlese! Sweet but not to the point of syrupy. Decent finish on this #Riesling — 6 years ago

with Bill

Bill Bender

9.5

Pure!! Thank you @Carl Fischer this was outstanding and the perfect fit for the venue and company — 7 years ago

Bill Bender

9.2

Gifted by @Carl Fischer in absentia. Golden straw hues, baked apple. A weighty feel but not cloying and I didn't get any over eager oak here at all. — 7 years ago

Martin G Rivard

9.6

@Carl Fischer Christine knew that we would all get along as soon as you walked in with this beauty in New York earlier this year!!! It's one of her favorites!!! Truly A phenomenal example of a great Napa cab. This is firing on all cylinders. I still have a dozen left in my cellar and can't wait to see the evolution that they will take in the next 15 years. Winner, winner chicken dinner! Great minds think a like Carl! LOL we must've had 60 bottles of wine that night and I still remember Christine saying "I really like that wine" when you walked in the door with that bottle! LOL The entire WNH @Joe Lucca @Mike Rowe @David L @Ron R would've had an incredible time this evening. We can't wait to see you within the near future! — 7 years ago

with Ryan and Christine

Jakub Kalinowski

9.3

Still a baby with a fresh nose of herby grapefruit, shy lime and cool wet mountain stream pebbles.
Brilliant concentration on the palate with this electric tension, racy acidity and a tight core of salty, slate minerality. Around this are layers of lime, white peach, ripe lemons. Ripe yet with great poise, focus and depth.
They really nailed it in 2020! — 3 years ago

Diana Bizjak

9.1

Very zesty, fruity, tart, and full-bodied. Really beautiful, smooth mouthfeel. Killer with Chinese food. — 5 years ago

Emily Anderson

9.4

Trying to make up for not making it to the kafer tent this year. Drinking with wiesnhendl tonight. @Christian W. Liedtke — 6 years ago

Casey Curbow

Sales Associate Windsor Wine Merchants

9.2

First Carl Loewen experience and certainly not last. — 6 years ago

David L

9.5

06’ @Carl Fischer Just another fantastic bottle. Breaking out this 2006... special one. Thanks for sharing. — 7 years ago

with Martin, Joe and 2 others

David Walser

8.9

Enjoyed on January 6, 2017. This bottle seemed a bit weaker than previous bottles I've had. — 7 years ago

Martin G Rivard

8.9

@David L @Carl Fischer @Ron R @Joe Lucca @Kirk Alexander Christine & I had dinner with my buddy Kirk and his beatific wife Veronica. I uncorked this one since it had been such a reliable pour the last time I opened it. However, in New York it had disappointed all of us. I am back to being disappointed. This is the type of bottle that you have to open by itself and not showcase it against any other as it will swiftly retreat into the shadows. Light on the palate, super short finish. This bottle came in dead last tonight. I can't believe the other that I opened impressed me that much that night. I don't do this often but I will knock it down to an 8.9. — 7 years ago

with Christine

Sarah Pennock

10

Sweet, but not overly. — 4 years ago

Ken F

8.9

Nice fruity wine with Debbie at home with a pot of sauce — 5 years ago

Wivino Mann

9.2

Versteigerung Kabinett — 6 years ago

with Jörg, Christian and 1 other

B

10

1993 Domaine Georges de Vogue Chambolle Musigny. Fam dinner w IK at Carl Gar. Poured out of the bottle. No decanting. Perfect. — 6 years ago

Martin G Rivard

9.4

Awesome wine., I’ve never had! My 1st and I️ only had a sip 😢.
the consensus was that it was a hit. Thank you Carl for sharing this beauty with us! — 7 years ago

with Joe, Carl and 4 others

Martin G Rivard

9.6

@Ron R @Mike R @David L @Howard Greenfield @Kirk Alexander @Joe Lucca @Carl Fischer @Paul T @Bill Bender @Ted Mandes @Jim Trobaugh @Monica O @Terri Walker @Steve Colanero My amazing friend Steve Colanero is a retired chef. We enjoyed an amazing dinner in his home this evening and opened these 2 beauties. Becklyn Reserve and a private propriety blend called "M" by Ted Mandes.
I opened and reviewed the Becklyn Reserve last night as well. You all know how I felt about it. Extremely solid and I rated accordingly. My opinion hasn't changed. It's an awesome wine. Thanks again David for introducing me to this Beauty!! — 7 years ago

with Ted, Steve and 1 other

Morgan

9.2

Great memories of sitting in the backyard of Winebar. Yummy wine. 2013 — 8 years ago