Matt Nason

9.4

Beautiful acidity with green apple and almond skin. — 5 years ago

Ed Chin

8.9

Tons of apple — 6 years ago

Pat Carroll

10

An all time fav, apple, light peach, spatlese sweetness. No petrol notes. — 7 years ago

Peter Sultan

9.3

Dont drink the last two bottles, note to self! Another zelig of whites, so much development to go but is drinking prettily now. Still young w much snappy apple-ness, encased in a yeasty & mineral pearl. Had w mussels in saki & parsley, & simply sauteed trout. Yum — 7 years ago

with Owen

Rebecca Fletcher

9.8

Ripe yellow Apple and pear. Minerality. Honey, butter, lemon, and wet stone. M+ acid. M body. Bit bitter on the front palate. Honeycomb, m+ finish and complexity. — 9 years ago

James McFadyen

Wine Consultant and Allocation Specialist at Spec's

8.9

Just lovely, as always a beautiful example.
Bright crisp, with great crunchy Apple, lanolin, melon and Chalky minerals. — 10 years ago

A R

9.5

Fantastic value. Green apple, citrus, pear. Great nose, great finish. — 11 years ago

Mira Rodgers

9.5

Beautiful notes of honey, pear, golden apple with musky, mushroom notes. Very light style with notes of oxidation and an afterthought of carbonation. — 5 years ago

with Kamee

Michael Winterbottom

9.4

New world Chablis emulation but with a little more ripe fruit character and butter notes. Butter mochi, ripe green apple, cooked apples. Really tart finish with duality if fruit character. 0 new oak usage in this wine, fermented in used oak barrels and battonage for a year. Not your typical Napa chardonnay by any means but elegant and pretty. Perfumed and pretty. — 7 years ago

David Price

9.1

Very good. Crisp, smooth, good amount of acidity. Fruits of pear, apricot and a hint of apple. — 7 years ago

Severn Goodwin

9.0

Only Randall could imagine this unique combination. — 8 years ago

Mike Fifer

Writer The Wine Monologues

8.9

Quite simply a crowd pleaser. Notes of peaches, apple, nectarine. Nice acidity and balance. And a great QPR. Well done Charles Smith yet again. — 9 years ago

Rob Moose

9.2

Subtly perfumey and very easy to cash — 11 years ago

Max Coane

9.0

Not corked. Apricot. Melon skin. Yellow apple. A little oxidized but not in a bad way. — 12 years ago

Brian S

9.0

Baked yellow apple brûlée, wild strawberry, more lessy, a bit of funk. — 6 years ago

Peter Marks

Master of Wine, Educator Constellation Brands

9.1

Toasted brioche and apple crumble. Gorgeous creamy and rich and definitely needs to be consumed now. — 7 years ago

with Marie and Adrienne

Bob Dylan

9.7

Dry floral funky so good — 7 years ago

Eric Vrtis

9.0

Just good enough to fall into the love category. Loads of limestone and lees with citrus blossom, tart green apple, honeydew rind. Creamy mouthfeel. — 9 years ago

Rebecca Fletcher

9.5

Pear, Apple, brioche, lemon zest, white pepper and white flowers. M+ acid, m body, citrus and minerality. Rich full body, creamy. Long finish. — 10 years ago

Jason Schulz

10

As terrific as always! Great acidity, beautiful tart apple, just delicious! — 11 years ago