Willem Jan Withagen

8.9

Had this bottle for a long time already. And thought it to be a basic peaty Islay. But it is a very fine rounded, bit sweet and not too agressive. Better get a new one. — 6 years ago

Al

9.2

Nice peat! — 7 years ago

with Brenda and Lois

Tim Maloney

9.5

Actually having the 12 year Scotch. Dark color and very smooth. One of the best. — 7 years ago

Phillip Antley

9.0

So much peat and smoke. Also more subtle grassy notes and earthy sweetness. Super light-bodied. A great Islay scotch. — 8 years ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.0

SD 11/18/16 — 8 years ago

Richard Sohn

9.5

Honey followed by wisp of smoldering campfire. The perfect balance of everything? — 9 years ago

Ryan Frank

9.3

Sweet, spicy, and bottled at just the right age and proof. Spectacular offering from #Balvenie. — 9 years ago

Riccardo L.

9.7

Smokey camp fire. Smoke on the nose, smoke in your mouth. Smokey smoke everywhere. ABSOLUTELY PHENOMENAL. Definitely an acquired taste, but once acquired, little else comes close... — 10 years ago

Simon Burke-Kennedy

9.5

Very delicious! — 11 years ago

Deborah Heath

9.6

Islay flight #2: Kilchoman Machir Bay. From Islay's newest distillery. Heady convergence of peat, flowers, fresh mown grass — 11 years ago

Christian Fischer

9.3

Smokey and smooth. Very nice — 6 years ago

Leonard Huot

9.0

Nice one shared with Jared in nyc — 7 years ago

Tim Maloney

9.3

Very peaty color. Sharp to the nose. Sharp, stingy and mineral flavor with a long finish. Not for the weak of heart and fantastic! — 7 years ago

Eric

9.1

Good scotch for the price. — 7 years ago

OG

9.9

Bloody good. It had to be as it cost the price of a small duchy.
I have a whole bottle of this greatness with me. Not a good idea.
Taste is sort of dry, not sweet and not bitter...all in equal mix. Taste of lots of stuff. It's been through different cask apparently. Bourbon, Madeira, Port...
Lovely aroma. Doesn't come to hit you right back. — 8 years ago

Michael McNabb

9.6

Wow!!! Orange marmalade and ginger. An outstanding whiskey! — 9 years ago

Bryan Hanggi

9.0

Amazing nutty, candied — 9 years ago

Dave Harris

9.3

Macallan 12. Great integration of caramel and peat. — 10 years ago

Terence Tan

9.0

A drink with character. Good balance with depth and with slight smokiness. — 10 years ago

Philippe Dauguet

9.4

Tourbe magnifique et équilibrée — 11 years ago

Shannon Kerr

9.5

Spicy, lots of flavor — 7 years ago

Martin G Rivard

10

@Bill Bender Wish you and the remainder of the 🍷Wine Nerd Herd🍷 were here right now! This baby is going down so ever so smoothly! You would really dig it! And so would they!!! — 7 years ago

with Christine

Alex Randell

9.5

The regular. — 7 years ago

Sander Schaap

9.5

Batch 9, bottled feb. 2017. — 8 years ago

Ichiro Kawachi

9.2

Konbu soy sauce kelp blast — 8 years ago

Carla Lalalalalalala

9.8

Whisky + Sauternes = Fave :-) — 9 years ago

Richard Parkhouse

9.2

Washed down with some water from a Scottish loch... — 9 years ago

M L

9.1

Smooth, little citrus, trace of nut. Excellent finish. — 10 years ago

Maxence Guilluy

10

Light, sweet and honey aromas — 11 years ago

Chris VanHoose

9.9

I love scotch.. scotchy scotch scotch down into my belly — 11 years ago