Robert Harmelin

9.3

Superb has great aging potential can’t wait to see how things develop over the next 10 years — 9 years ago

Keith Browning

9.4

Superb out of magnum; rich fruit and great balance — 9 years ago

Robert Cunningham

Wine Educator DeVinimus, Wine Workshop

9.5

Superb perfume and elegance — 9 years ago

Sasha Agapov

9.8

Nutty, honeyed and deliciously complex. Just superb! — 10 years ago

Robert Cunningham

Wine Educator DeVinimus, Wine Workshop

9.5

Superb Calon Segur!! One of the wines of the night. Balanced, developed, and showing beautifully. — 10 years ago

Trevor Maskell

9.3

Not a bad 700th wine ;) beautifully balanced. Superb mouthfeel. Still on the youthful side. Gentle and composed. Lingering flavours. — 10 years ago

LM Segal

9.3

2013. Superb. Was expecting infanticide and discovered a prodigy. Lighter side of Syrah, perfectly delineated after 1 hr decant. Feminine, lithe lens on allspice, lavender, bacon fat. Swathe of fine tannins. This will evolve for decades, so nicely structured, but worth trying now. As good as the pricier VV I tried last year. — 11 years ago

Martin Davies

9.3

Superb. However worryingly tasted like actual wine. Hopefully this will resolve itself as it ages. — 11 years ago

Robert Malinzak

10

Excellent nose. The finish is superb. — 12 years ago

Shervin Talieh

9.3

Now I get it. Superb. The 2009 could stand 2-3 more years but delightful today. Exceptional. — 13 years ago

John Osgood

10

Superb young Cabernet. — 9 years ago

with Randy

Jen

9.4

Superb and still quite lovely. And lively. — 9 years ago

Andrew Brenner

9.5

Superb bottle. Bright acid, blueberry, tobacco and herbs. Accompany to an outstanding meal. — 10 years ago

Harry C

9.2

Superb - beautifully balanced, delicate, and elegant. Smooth, lush, finish that just melts in your mouth. — 10 years ago

Robert Cunningham

Wine Educator DeVinimus, Wine Workshop

9.6

Superb, long lived and exquisitely balanced. Almost as good as the 59. Number 2 wine of this Latour vertical. — 10 years ago

Mitja Sirk

Production La Subida, Aceto Sirk

9.1

Perfect start!! Superb — 11 years ago

with Marta and Giampaolo

LM Segal

9.6

Kudos to the boys for all calling it CdP, GV even nailed it a Pegau blind. Bramble, tar and hint of garrigue. Rich, distinctive nose. Amazingly still coming together after 3 hr decant, the pieces all there: beef blood, earth, peppery spice, pipe tobacco. Big tannins on the precipice of melting down and perfectly melding it all together. Just a few years before this passes superb on its way to profound. — 11 years ago

David

9.6

I owned a case of this and consumed most of it way too early. The last couple of bottles were perfectly aged and this was a superb Bordeaux. — 12 years ago

Adrian Bryksa

Blogger YYCWine.com, Contributor Culinaire

9.7

Superb - gorgeous structure, acidity with bright fruit. Still a baby. — 12 years ago

Kevin Kinsella

9.8

Superb 2005 Harlan Estate, enjoying it with Ed and Rose O'Sullivan — 14 years ago

with Paten

Paul van Maaren

9.6

Currently in a great place, well balanced, pure and precise with warm gravel and earthy, delicate red berry silky texture - superb — 9 years ago

Greg Lowe

9.6

Surprisingly youthful nose of luscious rich plummy baked dark red fruits and the most etheral sous bois and pipe tobacco I've ever smelled. The palate had poise and grace in its age, everything was in fantastic balance. The tannins are shockingly fine, adding the structure that is necessary to hold everything together. Simply superb. I can only hope I show as well as this when I'm nearly 65! — 9 years ago

Pascal Jeangirard

9.0

A great wine for a great evening Had it with a selection of cheeses absolutely superb, vintage 1984. — 10 years ago

Lewis Chester

9.6

2006 vintage. At Au Fil du Zinc, Chablis. Pale garnet hue. Savoury, Earth and manure nose, red currant and wild strawberry, red cherry. On the palate, medium acidity, medium body, medium plus alcohol. Full concentration. Long long finish. Licorice, mint, savoury spices, the whole shebang. More evolved than the '05. Superb. — 10 years ago

Kirk Wallace

9.7

Wotn. Topped he '94 Montrose, which was superb. This had everything. At a plateau, but no signs of imminent fading. Do they still make left bank Bordeaux like this? — 10 years ago

Peter Mansell

9.0

Took a while to open but then superb — 11 years ago

Mirelsa Modestti

9.4

Superb craftsmanship. Joseph Phelps means business with this Insignia. Beautiful aftertaste. — 11 years ago

Jerry Bias

9.6

Superb from start to finish. Robust nose of dark cherry, tobacco and earth. Taste is amazing. Dances on your tongues tip..meanders to the center of your tongue with all the body one can endure....and finishes with you longing for more...whew...I think i need a smoke after that! — 11 years ago

Tom Kobylarz

10

A prefect Claret color, intense but translucent ruby. The aroma is noticeable from the hip, flowers like violets, sweet cedar, mature plum and cassis rise effortlessly from the glass. The palate is strength without effort, superb length, freshness and purity. — 12 years ago

Wally Jackpot

10

Spectacular, superb, long lasting full taste — 13 years ago

with Trex