Jose Lorenzo

9.0

A baby. Will wait at least 5 yrs to open the next. — 7 months ago

Bob Boyle

9.3

Opened the first night and not impressed, was closed but the following night it opened and morphed into a wonderful balanced wine with cocoa notes in the nose, full body and great finish. — 9 months ago

KA

9.3

En magnum — 10 months ago

Harri Sharman

9.0

Chewy ripe tannins, sour cherry and dried cranberries, wet leather and graphite? — 10 years ago

Heather Rostker

9.4

Going back in time for this one. Let it sit a little and it opened right up. — 8 months ago

with Emmett and Brian

Ki Punwar

Owner, California Wine Republic

9.3

Initially tannic but this is full bodied and lush as it opened up — 9 months ago

Richard Rosensweig

9.1

Pipeau is an early foray into 2005 for me. Not a bad place to start. Very round structure. Full fruit with stewed plum, black cherry, slate, hint of mint. A little dry on the finish. Will mellow in the next few years. — 9 years ago

Doug Powers

9.3

Sweet vanillin, dried red fruits, still quite fresh and clean, medium-bodied, resolved tannins, but the bright acidity really carries this into a long, lingering finish, my wife’s favorite Bordeaux, alas only a few more bottles left in the cellar!! — 8 months ago

with Jim

KP

9.5

Beautiful, quintessential nose! Silky and balanced from start to finish. Not trying to be too bold but it doesn’t disappear either. Truly enjoyable Bordeaux and I would absolutely buy it again — 9 months ago

Neil Shah

9.2

Time in a bottle - florally — 10 years ago