Gunja Gargeshwari

9.3

Took a while to open up but then Pritchard hill came through and took my breath away! Think it was too cold when we opened the bottle - this one needs a decant! — 6 years ago

Martin G Rivard

9.6

Simply amazing., time really, really treated this one well. Amazing job Anthony!!!@Anthony Weytjens 🙌👏👏👏🙌👌 — 7 years ago

with Anthony

Martin G Rivard

9.7

Dark, lush and oh so Good!!
Everything I love in a Cab! Badass in a glass to say the least!
The only thing better tonight is my friendship with @Mike R ! I’m the lucky one that received this awesome bottle!!! Thank you my friend! — 8 years ago

with Christine

Keri Gawlik

9.8

Great structure, notes of apple and pear. I'm not typically a Chardonnay drinker but this one was very memorable!! — 8 years ago

Ken Rogers

9.2

Great complexity from one of our consistently favorite wineries. This one is very complex, and developed interestingly over two days. It's started out with a lot of brambly, earthy character, with very muted raspberry fruit, and the Russian River cherry cola fruit came out much more prominently in day 2. — 9 years ago

with Michael

Stephanie Losee

9.4

Drank a 35-year-old Rutherford Hill Napa Valley cab while getting our hearts broken last night. One good memory on a devastating night — 9 years ago

Edmond Bordelon

9.6

Surprisingly, this one was not as big as the Futo. I am a big fan of anything from Prichard Hill and was intrigued seeing this one on the list. Gave it an hour to open up and had a fantastic ribeye to pair it with! In retrospect, I think I would have flipped the sequence. (All bullshit aside on sequencing, this is still an amazing wine and I am just being anal).. The color was still a nice deep violet with strong dark fruits. Great pedigree with Helen Turley on the planting and David Abreu on the vineyard management. What could ever go wrong? — 6 years ago

Roger Custer

9.2

One of my favorites. Just the right amount of fruit, wood, and terroir. A bit acidic but not too much. Pairs nicely with cheese and charcuterie. — 7 years ago

Sarah Milsow-Guenther

9.5

Still one of my favorite Pinots. Sad this is my last bottle. Really dark in color, lots of fruit left, hints of earth. Absolutely lovely. — 7 years ago

Gerald Kelly

9.4

Give this one at least 2 hours to breathe after you open it and you will be greatly rewarded. Fabulous! — 8 years ago

Paul H

9.1

It is funny how things work. Some people have comfort foods, I have comfort wines. This Lucia Syrah just makes me happy. I love the spice, leather and dark berries in this wine. It is one of things in life you need to get you through some times. — 8 years ago

Sharon B

9.2

One of my favorite "go-to" wines! Medium body, smooth finish, nice and fruity. — 8 years ago

John Malcolm

9.3

Excellent! Oak, fig, lemon, and honeysuckle. Smooth with an oh-so-lovely aftertaste. So regretting that I only had one bottle in my cellar. — 9 years ago

Alicia Cypress

9.1

It’s been a bit since I’ve had a Sonoma Coast Pinot, and glad my entry back included this Cobb Jack Hill. Super pretty dark ruby fruit with a hint of blueberry and some stems on the backside. Needs a few years to show its true wonder, but I’m quite satisfied to be drinking after a dreary day in one of my favorite cafes. — 7 years ago

.

9.3

This is a wonderful wine - one of the best field blends I’ve had, really. There’s an impression of wild raspberries and boysenberries on the front end, backed by a layer of mildly peppery spice, and presented in a medium-bodied frame. The tannins are mostly resolved and the finish is clean and just a touch sweet. This was ready to go with minimal air.

This is only my second or third Bucklin and I’m becoming a big fan. — 7 years ago

Kirk F

9.3

Heard much about this one and all the build up did not disappoint. Delicious and oh so well balanced. — 8 years ago

Russell Glass

9.6

Probably one of the best Chardonnays have tasted from California or was that ...Chablis?
— 8 years ago

Paul T HB

9.8

Old school mag,
Seen better corks but wine is great!
Just keeps getting better, wow wine
This was Shafer 2005 good!
One of those wines you wish you had another one of for tomorrow, — 8 years ago

Tom Wood

9.1

I've never had one of these aged. This was blind tasted at a Gruner tasting and I immediately thought that this was in the line up as a curve ball. I could not believe how much this reminded me of Riesling from Mosel. ACE sorbet, canned peach, marmalade, butterscotch, kerosene and wet rock. Length, amazing structure. — 9 years ago

CMalcolm

9.2

One of my favorite Chardonnays. Smooth with a little bit of an oaky flavor. — 9 years ago