Château Lagrange

Saint-Julien Red Bordeaux Blend 2005

John Burke

8.9

Enjoining with the Rovi team in Barbados — 11 years ago

Mount Gay Distilleries Ltd.

Extra Old Barbados Rum

Josh MacGregor

9.1

If you're gonna drink rum, might as well be this. Average aged 8 - 15 years in bourbon barrels. — 13 years ago

Mount Gay Distilleries Ltd.

Eclipse Black 100 Proof Mount Gay Rum Sugar Cane

Kir Beardy

9.6

Favourite rum ever. Always must be on my table. — 13 years ago

Mount Gay Distilleries Ltd.

Black Barrel Rum

Jonas Johansson

9.8

Time to dress the Christmas tree — 13 years ago

Mount Gay Distilleries Ltd.

Silver Mount Gay Barbados Rum

Antoine Pin

Wine Buyer Kroger/QFC

9.4

I didn't know Mount Gay made a Silver!?! Love it! All of their products turn out to be very smooth. — 12 years ago

Dos Maderas

5 + 5 PX Aged Rum Sugar Cane

Kir Beardy

9.7

Very unusual rum. Cherry casks made their job very well - smell of cherry is awesome! — 13 years ago

Pusser's Rum

Antoine Pin

Wine Buyer Kroger/QFC

9.6

Second best rum. And this one's simple, but best for Painkillers. $34 / 94pts — 13 years ago

Caribaya

Cream Rum

Sheila E Cooper

Taste Of The Caribbean — 12 years ago

Cruzan

St. Croix Black Strap Rum

Kendall Levine

9.3

Kendall had this 12 years ago

with Geraldine

Geraldine Prasuhn

Maple syrup and molasses really are overwhelming. But I wanna try mixing this with maple syrup to go with pancakes during a boozy brunch.

8.2

Geraldine Prasuhn

Also needs a really spicy gingerbeer that can balance these flavors in a dark and stormy

Mount Gay Distilleries Ltd.

Extra Old Molasses Barbados Rum

Antoine Pin

Wine Buyer Kroger/QFC

8.9

All time best rum. Drinks like a cognac. $NA / 97pts — 13 years ago