Nicholas Brooks

9.6

Colgin Tasting - 2006. While it's a Parker 100 wine it wasn't the pick on the day. Still lovely with a velvety well integrated tannin blanket giving the dark fruit a superb base to bind itself to. Excellent length. Now, I've heard people bang on about this wine - 2012, but I know there are mixed reviews. While the diehard Napa peeps have no issue paying big money for this, I wonder if they are buying into the label more than the wine. It's said to be a superb vintage over all. In the glass it was your typical sweeter Bordeaux-esque wine. I'd suggest a little too warm. 2013 (66% Cab, 25% Merlot, and the rest of its friends). Great wine. Time will tell if the discussion of 2013 being better than 2012 will be true in general. But I did enjoyed this a little more than '12. Great length and the same great tannin matrix. Young and chewy, but you know where it's going. She's a keeper. — 7 years ago

Rakesh Tondon

10

Drinking some good stuff with close friends — 8 years ago

Christopher Ashcroft

10

An old favourite! Brioche on a beautiful level. Biscuity and smooth. Enjoyed best with friends — 9 years ago

Jamie Smith

9.4

Great wine with great friends — 9 years ago

with Brendan

Wilfred Wong

Chief Storyteller, Wine.com

9.8

Almost 60 years, both the wine and me when I drank it in Paris, with very good friends. I felt great and the wine tasted really super. Served blind, I called it a very well aged Pauillac. I thought it was a younger wine.😏 #bordeaux #paris #pauillac #pichonbaron — 10 years ago

Erich Broksas

Early Mountain Vineyards

9.3

Love the RdV Friends and Family. Unfortunately it is no longer being released. — 11 years ago

Albertine Shaffer

10

Albertine had this 8 years ago

Doreen Sylvia Dunlevy

9.1

This wine was a gift from friends staying at our condo. You are welcome back anytime. Rich, robust red wine, great with pasta! Perfect! — 8 years ago

Amanda Igra

9.0

A lovely bottle to share with friends at dinner. Nice fruit, tobacco, nice body. — 9 years ago

Fabio Sisinni

10

celebrating birthday with great friends and its majesty Caymus. Cabernet sauvignon perfection — 9 years ago

Josh Spurling

10

If you don't like this wine, we can't be friends any more. — 10 years ago

Austin Baird

9.1

Lovely Cab. Great Orin Swift wine, enjoyed this magnum late at night for a friends birthday! — 10 years ago

James Parker Huston, CWE

Sommelier Charlie Palmer

9.9

Much success in 2014 my friends. The Comtesse is singing. — 10 years ago

Danny Rubio

9.2

This is a very nice one. Great to have with poultry and pork and maybe some red meat. It's smooth very nice but at the same time it's not too sweet not too dry period the kind of wine that you want to sit around just chatting with friends and enjoying life. — 8 years ago

Joe Nemeth

10

This old and empty bottle I drank with friends and family members on my Birthday it's a Magnum and wasn't as well cared for as another Magnum of Chateau Talbot also a 1949 Magnum also drank on my birthday with friends who as well as me, are old farts or dead. I'm still kicking but not a clue as to why? Possibly the fine wine I/we consumed? The Talbot was considerably better and I paid less for it back in the 70's. Drank it in 1979 it & me were 30 back then. I loved it then and my guess is I'd love it today!
From my, "For What it's Worth Department!" Joe — 8 years ago

Keinan Ashkenazi

9.5

Wonderful super Tuscan with a nice blend of spice and berries. Enjoying with friends in Capri at the Relais La Palma — 9 years ago

Jerome Noël

9.3

Pairs well with friends. — 9 years ago

Karen Hunt

9.0

This was amazing and with amazing friends — 10 years ago

Leon Levitt

9.7

Celebrating NYE with good friends jay and Charlotte the right way! — 10 years ago

Kathleen Azzarello

9.6

Sharing this with friends on New Year's Eve. Thanks Meg and Jason for this fab Pinot Noir! — 11 years ago