Angelo Casagrande

9.1

Fragrant chard with apple/ pear w a hint of citrus on the finish. Excellent acidity and some stony minerality. Bright and welcoming. Tom- it may be trying to pass itself off as a more haughty cotes de beaune, however. — 4 days ago

Jonas Hartz

8.9

Didn’t knock me off my feet. Never blossomed to its true potential — 5 months ago

Fredybeans

9.1

Précis et terrien
Fruit rouge et épicé
Evolue très bien — 3 years ago

John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

9.1

The best of the three we tried from this producer. Mandarin, lemon, slate, fresh nose. — a month ago

Mark S.

8.9

Violet, plum, vanilla and cosmic. Roses. Slight sweet. Berries. Concentration. Balanced acidity and spiciness. David Renaud Irancy Vaupessiot 19 @3850, Umem, 241121-241126 — 5 months ago

Damian

9.1

Plum, baking spices and peppery notes. Long finish. — 6 months ago

Fabian Kühlhorn

9.2

Opens up with lemon and a hint of vanilla. I have not encountered vanilla like this in these wines before, or maybe I mistook it for something else. Anyway, a bit rounded in the corners, fruit just starting to develop. Very good now, great future ahead. — 3 years ago

Tom Casagrande

9.0

My second bottle in a little over two months, it seems better than the first bottle. A little more of everything. Lots of pure apple fruit, nice minerality. Nice concentration and balance, with less prominent alcohol than my first bottle. Very nice glass of wine! — 3 months ago

Chris Buggy

9.2

Blackberry blueberry perfume, raspberry currant, medium tannins, lasted on the palate. Superb — 6 months ago

with Jennifer

Matthew Cohen

9.3

Dark color 14%

Nose: inky cassis. Some herbals.

Palate: dark fruits. Graphite. Delicious.

Shiverick $24 — 9 months ago