Carl Weinberg

Detert Family Vineyards

Oakville Cabernet Franc 2012

Shay A
9.5

When @Carl Fischer and I did our cab franc swap, we sent a few solid Cab francs and other misc wine, but the main reason for the swap was trading our favorite cab franc...for me, the Arnyca, and for Carl, the Detert. After finally opening this up, I can see what all the hype is about. This is pure, big boy cab franc. Deep royal purple in the glass. Although Carl recommended a decant, I wanted a small taste at pop and pour...hey-o! This sucker flexed its muscles, punched me in the face, and said "you'll wait". At about an hour and a half in the decanter, this opened BEAUTIFULLY. Violet, blackberry pie, sweet tobacco on the nose. Great acidity and mouthfeel. Chewy blackberries on the palate. This beaut of a cab franc will age so nicely. Oh man, I need to try one of these at about the 7-10yr mark. Bravo, @Carl Fischer ! You made me a believer (and my fellow cork monkey in the pic). — 10 years ago

Jason, Brandon and 36 others liked this
Jeff D.

Jeff D. Influencer Badge

@Carl Fischer the Moulds Vineyard and Atlas are also exceptional!!
Carl Fischer

Carl Fischer Influencer Badge

@Jeff D. - have not tried the Atlas but love the Moulds. They also have a really nice Sauv Blanc.
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Carl Fischer : FYI, this Detert is making swoon on day 2! So freaking good!

Carl Reh

Riesling

Good riesling. Little sweet for my taste but still pretty good. — 11 years ago

"Odedi" liked this

Krug

Grande Cuvée Brut Champagne Blend

Wonderful wine to end a weekend. Thanks @Alan Weinberg ! — 11 years ago

Elise Weinberg
with Elise

Carl Graff

Graacher Himmelreich Riesling

A personal favorite. — 11 years ago

Jenni Kluz
with Jenni

Carl Loewen

Quant Riesling 2011

A lot of value to be found (lol) in German Gutsweinen. Clean, fruit, easy, not very dry. — 12 years ago

Christopher liked this

Weingut Carl Ehrhard

Rüdesheimer Berg Rottland Spatlese Riesling 1994

Apples dipped in honey. Love these old rieslings — 12 years ago

Carl Roy

East Side Cuvee Cabernet Sauvignon 2009

Bananas. Light, easy going tannins. Could still go for a year or two but immensely drinkable. — 12 years ago

Jeff Pitts
with Jeff

Carl Schmitt-Wagner

Longuicher Maximiner Herrenberg Kabinett Riesling 2012

Chris Morgan
9.1

100 yaer-old vines! — 13 years ago

Brian Brill
with Brian

Becklyn Cellars

Reserve Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon

@Ron R @Mike R @David L @Howard Greenfield @Kirk Alexander @Joe Lucca @Carl Fischer @Paul T @Bill Bender @Ted Mandes @Jim Trobaugh @Monica O @Terri Walker @Steve Colanero My amazing friend Steve Colanero is a retired chef. We enjoyed an amazing dinner in his home this evening and opened these 2 beauties. Becklyn Reserve and a private propriety blend called "M" by Ted Mandes.
I opened and reviewed the Becklyn Reserve last night as well. You all know how I felt about it. Extremely solid and I rated accordingly. My opinion hasn't changed. It's an awesome wine. Thanks again David for introducing me to this Beauty!!
— 10 years ago

Ted MandesSteve ColaneroChristine
with Ted, Steve and 1 other
Martin, Steve and 32 others liked this
Martin G Rivard

Martin G Rivard Influencer Badge

@David Goldfinger Totally forgot to tag you on this one!
Steve Colanero

Steve Colanero

My Friend brought this wine to my home. It was very good but I can't rate it as high as Martin. Sorry buddy

Carter Cellars

Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2005

Holy shit this is good!! A&J vineyard
@Carl Fischer @Ron R @David A Lentine I must have opened a bad bottle in New York. If you guys remember, we tasted it and literally threw it away. Decanted this for two hours and it is absolutely blowing up! Firing on all cylinders. Full-bodied, flowers spice and everything that's nice! LOL. For the life of me, I feel as if I almost get a little forest floor out of it. Truly amazing wine.!! 😍🍷🍷😍.
Carl, you and I distinctively hated this when we uncorked it in New York. You would not even recognize this bottle! It's amazing! Have a great Thanksgiving my friends!
— 10 years ago

Martin, Ryan and 32 others liked this
Martin G Rivard

Martin G Rivard Influencer Badge

@Bill Bender Happy thanksgiving bud!
Mike Smith

Mike Smith Influencer Badge

Nils made this wine
Norman

Norman Premium Badge

I was disappointed with the Carter I opened. I think the lack of a decant was my mistake. Great to hear this one shined.

Carl Roy

Mt. Veeder Cabernet Sauvignon 2013

Diamond Mountain. Not much different than the East Side Cuvée. — 11 years ago

Carl Everson

Chenin Blanc 2014

Exquisite Chenin Blanc with soft pear notes. Stunning. — 11 years ago

Carl Schmitt-Wagner

Longuicher Maximiner Herrenberg Auslese Riesling 2001

Nice balance. Some age on nose. — 12 years ago

Anthony, Veronica and 1 other liked this

Carl Graff

Piesporter Michelsberg Spätlese Riesling 2006

We are drinking the 2006 vintage. Beautiful, unctuous, silky. Canned peaches in heavy syrup with the acidity to make it work. May need to go back for another bottle. — 12 years ago

Stevie, Sharon and 1 other liked this

Carl Loewen

Thörnicher Ritsch Auslese Riesling 2005

Lychee, kiwi, stone fruit, grapefruit, honeycomb, etc. Tasted like a cross between a Loire Chenin Blanc and a Hungarian Tokaji. Outstanding! — 12 years ago

Gries

Baron Carl Eyrl Alto Adige - Südtirol Grieser Lagrein 2011

It rocked with braised pork belly and fennel! — 13 years ago

Paul Mabray
with Paul
Paul and Fabien liked this

Carl Loewen

Leiwener Laurentiuslay Auslese Riesling 2003

Very a typisch but, sexy wine. Quit sweet and thick full off layers of caramel, butterscotch and sweet ripe peaches. — 13 years ago

TOR Kenward Family Wines

Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2012

@Carl Fischer Christine knew that we would all get along as soon as you walked in with this beauty in New York earlier this year!!! It's one of her favorites!!! Truly A phenomenal example of a great Napa cab. This is firing on all cylinders. I still have a dozen left in my cellar and can't wait to see the evolution that they will take in the next 15 years. Winner, winner chicken dinner! Great minds think a like Carl! LOL we must've had 60 bottles of wine that night and I still remember Christine saying "I really like that wine" when you walked in the door with that bottle! LOL The entire WNH @Joe Lucca @Mike Rowe @David L @Ron R would've had an incredible time this evening. We can't wait to see you within the near future! — 10 years ago

Ryan CallahanChristine
with Ryan and Christine
Martin, Eric and 26 others liked this
Ron R

Ron R Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Yep, can't wait, either!
David L

David L Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Martin G Rivard Many good times ahead.
Carl Fischer

Carl Fischer Influencer Badge

Nice!!! And thanks for a memory of such a fun night. Look forward to a repeat soon!

Carl Sittmann

Spätlese Late Harvest Riesling

Very nice, but a somewhat acidic aftertaste — 10 years ago

Wachter-Wiesler

Ried Weinberg 2013

Cherry cola. — 11 years ago

Carl Loewen

Maximin Herrenberg Alte Reben Trocken Riesling 2014

What a great dry Mosel Riesling! ungrafted vines from the former Carl Schmitt-Wagner vineyard, based on red slate. It combines all: length, minerality, yellow fruit and a gret elegance. — 11 years ago

KW liked this

Weingut Carl Ehrhard

Rüdesheimer Kirchenpfad Trocken Spätburgunder 2012

First German Pinot Noir I have ever had. Never loved German wines but this wine is delish. Soft and bold. Back cherry and oak. — 11 years ago

Dom NMiguel Nistal
with Dom and Miguel
Miguel liked this

Carl Reh

Piesporter Michelsberg Spätlese Riesling

$14 Really smooth, not a lot of acidity but good & balanced flavor. Most people will enjoy this wine. Rating: 91 — 13 years ago