Very nice, but a somewhat acidic aftertaste — 10 years ago
Fantastic! — 10 years ago
Lovely fruity with vanilla. Good with smoked trout — 11 years ago
A lot of value to be found (lol) in German Gutsweinen. Clean, fruit, easy, not very dry. — 12 years ago
Apples dipped in honey. Love these old rieslings — 12 years ago
Mouth-watering delicious — 12 years ago
Rheinhessen 2010er Woellsteiner Aeffchen Silvaner Eiswein — 14 years ago
Blackberry jam, currant flavors, visibly aged, very dark, some light chocolate flavors. Rich like a Cabernet Sauvignon. 2007. — 10 years ago
Holy shit this is good!! A&J vineyard
@Carl Fischer @Ron R @David A Lentine I must have opened a bad bottle in New York. If you guys remember, we tasted it and literally threw it away. Decanted this for two hours and it is absolutely blowing up! Firing on all cylinders. Full-bodied, flowers spice and everything that's nice! LOL. For the life of me, I feel as if I almost get a little forest floor out of it. Truly amazing wine.!! 😍🍷🍷😍.
Carl, you and I distinctively hated this when we uncorked it in New York. You would not even recognize this bottle! It's amazing! Have a great Thanksgiving my friends! — 10 years ago

Good riesling. Little sweet for my taste but still pretty good. — 11 years ago
Diamond Mountain. Not much different than the East Side Cuvée. — 11 years ago
WClub #2- Searing acidity — 11 years ago
Fieldtrip Feinherb — 12 years ago
Spot on spätburgunder — 12 years ago
Bananas. Light, easy going tannins. Could still go for a year or two but immensely drinkable. — 12 years ago
$14 Really smooth, not a lot of acidity but good & balanced flavor. Most people will enjoy this wine. Rating: 91 — 13 years ago
Delicious! — 14 years ago
@Carl Fischer Christine knew that we would all get along as soon as you walked in with this beauty in New York earlier this year!!! It's one of her favorites!!! Truly A phenomenal example of a great Napa cab. This is firing on all cylinders. I still have a dozen left in my cellar and can't wait to see the evolution that they will take in the next 15 years. Winner, winner chicken dinner! Great minds think a like Carl! LOL we must've had 60 bottles of wine that night and I still remember Christine saying "I really like that wine" when you walked in the door with that bottle! LOL The entire WNH @Joe Lucca @Mike Rowe @David L @Ron R would've had an incredible time this evening. We can't wait to see you within the near future! — 10 years ago

One of our favourites. — 10 years ago
Dig now, but this is one that seems like it'd age amazingly well. — 11 years ago
What a great dry Mosel Riesling! ungrafted vines from the former Carl Schmitt-Wagner vineyard, based on red slate. It combines all: length, minerality, yellow fruit and a gret elegance. — 11 years ago
A little herbaceous, a little smokey meat, pretty darn good. 2012. — 12 years ago
Lychee, kiwi, stone fruit, grapefruit, honeycomb, etc. Tasted like a cross between a Loire Chenin Blanc and a Hungarian Tokaji. Outstanding! — 12 years ago
100 yaer-old vines! — 13 years ago
Max Kelly
Wow - superb concentration here. Quite thick and sweet on he attack with citrus and flowers, but searing - and I do mean searing - acidity and grip on the back end. Needs time for the two elements to meld together into a more harmonious whole, but this is a lot of wine for $21. — 10 years ago