Andres Alonso

9.1

2017 vintage. Wonderful, full bodied, with apple and honey notes, but acidic balance to offset the sweet notes. Great bargain for its quality! — a month ago

Bob McDonald

9.4

A solid rich Ruby red with no tawny rim. Looks way younger than 27 years. An earthy, plummy leathery perfume with same earthy, plummy and minerally medium to full bodied palate - a sweaty saddle classic old Hunter Valley style. Medium plus intensity of flavour with great persistence. Demonstrates the amazing longevity of old vine Hunter Valley Shiraz. I think you could safely drink this into the late 2020s. Honouring the Hunter Valley legend, Maurice O’Shea, who made great wine in primitive conditions In the late 1940s and 1950’s. About 15 years ago I had a 1952 Mount Pleasant Shiraz made by the great man - just medium bodied and still full of energy. — 2 years ago

Christo M

9.1

Butterrrrrr — 4 years ago

Kate Hufnagel

9.6

Happy 50th to JW and me 🎉 — a month ago

Norm

9.0

Very nice red blend for the finger lakes. This particular winery specializes only in red wines. Very nice atmosphere and they are wonderful hosts that are really knowledgeable. Winetasting would think you’re drinking California reds — 2 years ago

Ericsson

9.2

A Napa legend. — 3 years ago

Brian Don

9.2

From the MI Bday tasting, #2 of 5. Very good. — 4 years ago

Lee Pitofsky

9.9

The legend! En Magnum! Amazing wine. Just profound. One to remember… — 8 months ago

Boris Mathiszik

9.5

Revisiting the 15 vintage - dense and elegant, finely grained texture. There is just something inexplicably refined about this legend. — 2 years ago

Justin Bothur

9.2

So dense and earthy for this grape... dead ringer for high quality Cote-Rotie ... finally get to enjoy this legend! — 3 years ago