Unreal

Domaine Michel Rebourgeon

Les Noizons Pommard Pinot Noir 2024

Lyle Fass
9.6

Unreal. Cherry pit, concentration, big wine, darker fruit and amazing purity. Again, the tannins. — 5 months ago

Severn, Scott@Mister and 3 others liked this

Pierre Brisset

Cuvee Cassaneas Bourgogne Blanc Chardonnay 2023

Lyle Fass
9.6

Nose is stunning, baby Chassagne 1er Cru all the way: green apple skin, green apple flesh, white flowers, lime zest, lime flesh, and that clean Burgundian mineral snap. Palate is unreal: concentrated, savory, juicy, nimble, elegant, pure, bright, and mouthwatering. A little savory pull on the finish, with terrific length and energy. This is Chassagne Premier Cru quality, and I will die on that hill. After a few hours the finesse is off the charts. Stunning wine. 9.5 to 9.6. — 7 months ago

Dick, Zach and 6 others liked this

Michel Rebourgeon

Pommard Rugiens 1er Cru Pinot Noir 2018

Lyle Fass
9.6

I have not had in 6 years. Nose is gorgeous and brambly with huge sous bois, tiny whiff of oak, stunning spice and stoned along with some nice florals. Palate is a bit closed but super silky and not “tannin closed” like it was 6 years ago. Unreal fruit clarity and length. Air will help but great guts so far. Really classed up overnight. 9.5 to 9.6. So elegant and deep. Insanely clear fruit. — 9 months ago

Jay, Zach and 10 others liked this

Domaine Catherine Cuchet-Béliando

Cornas Syrah 2017

Lyle Fass
9.8

Unreal showing. — 10 months ago

Jay, Pooneet and 11 others liked this
Jay Kline

Jay Kline Influencer Badge Premium Badge

🐶
Lyle Fass

Lyle Fass Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Jay Kline drinking so so well. Needed maybe 30
mins
Jay Kline

Jay Kline Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Lyle Fass its been a few years since I had the 2017. Thanks for the heads up!

Rudolf Fürst

Centgrafenberg GG Riesling 2012

Lyle Fass
9.6

In the best spot right now. Unreal inner mouth aromas. Long. — 2 years ago

Erik, Severn and 4 others liked this

Martin Müllen

Trarbacher Huhnerberg Spätlese* trocken Mosel Riesling 2021

Lyle Fass
9.7

We got a future legend here. Nose js exotic citrus, herbs galore, slate, some pink grapefruit and apricot. Very expressive and super clear. There is also an umami aroma that is so enticing. Stunning. 9.7 nose. Palate is a dream. Citrus and sweet lime along with gorgeous clarity and freshness. This is ungodly fresh. Awesome grip, acidity and length yet ephemeral and light on its feet. So juicy and tangy with lovely salt notes on the finish. This is magic and has elite finesse why it is a 9.7 wine. Can’t wait to see what air does. Now with air the nose gets confectionary. Unreal variety of citrus now. Some sea air. Now the palate has a lemon lime citrus sweet tart aspect and is gaining some crunch. Wow what a finish. This is genius. — 3 years ago

Pinotman, Jay and 15 others liked this

Cave Sébastien Blachon

Margariat Saint-Joseph Syrah 2020

Lyle Fass
9.8

Nose is crazy. Purest olive i’ve smelled in years, green, black, kalamata, this is a 9.9 nose. so perfect. leather and red fruits but omg the olive explosion is crazy. so elegant and fine. big structure, and wonderful freshness, good acid and wonderful freshness. so so long. nose has so much granite after air. It’s so complex now. Just insane and so so pure. each time you stick your nose in this it gets more and more layered.
It’s rich and layered and unreal. genius and elegant and so so pure. Wonderful. amazing fruit.
— 3 years ago

Aravind, Ely and 7 others liked this

Marie Demets

La Fôret Extra Brut Champagne Blend 2019

Lyle Fass
9.8

Just an insane nose. So expansive, airy, salty, some fruit but more chalk and mineral, such a fine mousse, so elegant, juicy and clean, wonderful acidity, unreal purity, what a nose, the mousse is so clean and my god it’s so pure and has such movement. Sappy and dense but it floats like a cloud and finishes so dry but lingers. This is Brut Nature. Disgorged April 16, 2024. Nose keeps opening, lemon, pastry, so finesse. So fine. — 5 months ago

Zach, Scott@Mister and 4 others liked this

Weingut Möhr-Niggli

Pilgrim Pinot Noir 2023

Lyle Fass
9.7

Brilliant. Just brilliant. Nose is so round and luminous. Black, red cherry, spice, spicey oak, so complex and deep. The palate is just stunning. Soft and viscous with gorgeous satin like texture and juuuuuust short of sweet fruit and a bitter white chocolate note but finishes luscious and mineral. Terrific inner mouth aromas and such gorgeous delicate concentration and such fine tannins. Can’t wait to see what air does. So silky and sweet with air. Unreal texture. So elegant and just awesome fruit. Juicy and so clean. Mineral finish and such fine tannin. — 8 months ago

Ira, Zach and 7 others liked this

Sarl Garaudet Pere & Fils

Vieilles Vignes Meursault Chardonnay 2022

Lyle Fass
9.6

This is so good. Cooking now but more notes soon. It’s got this uncanny elegance on the palate plus this unreal concentration of sweet oak, minerals and fleshy fruit but backed up by ripping acids. Buttery Meursault but elevated beyond. — 9 months ago

Pinotman, Ron and 7 others liked this

Domaine Jean-Jacques Girard

Clos du Roi 1er Cru Beaune Pinot Noir 2023

Lyle Fass
9.5

One of the best Girard 23’s. First time since April and it’s just as I remember. What a wine. Lush, giving cherry nose that just exudes purity and generousness. So inviting. Palate is lush and generous with unreal fruit. Black cherry, red cherry, blackberry. So dense, so explosive and fresh. Gorgeous, diamond cut tannins. Unreal wine. Wow. — a year ago

Ray, Jay and 5 others liked this

Winzerhof Thörle

Saulheimer Kalkstein Spätburgunder 2022

Lyle Fass
9.6

Wow. Deep nose and super rich and ripe. Florals and violets. High toned nose and palate is so juicy and velvety and just unreal density and purity. Wow. Big tannins and ripe and so juicy. Super concentrated purple and cherry fruit. Unreal acidity. Wow. — 2 years ago

Ray, Jay and 7 others liked this

Ludovic Courbis

Cornas Syrah 2021

Lyle Fass
9.7

Nose has vanilla extract. Wild mint, herbs, red currant fruits, spice, granite tinged throughout. Insane palate of tiny berrt fruit explosion. Unreal finesse. So long and incredible. More soon. — 3 years ago

Daniel, Scott@Mister and 12 others liked this

Tenuta Monolo

Riserva Bramaterra Nebbiolo Blend 1994

Lyle Fass
9.6

Glorious nose of fresh woodshop shavings, dried cherry and dried roses plus smoke and wet earth. Also tree bark. The full mature nebbiolo symphony in effect. Cigar, tobacco, and so much more. This is singing. Some fresh mid season cherries are emerging with some coaxing. Gorgeous loamy minerality. What a nose. 9.5 nose for now. Juicy palate with high acidity and. blend of early season and sour cherries. Stunning purity and finesse. This is so so classy. Now with air the nose is getting layered and more complex. Tbis is a 9.6 now. Wow this is amazing. The finesse is top notch and the fruit is youthening up as it airs. Benjamin Button wine! Velvety tannins and sweet and sour cherry fruit. Complexity explosion on the finish. Simply stunning. After 24 hours the nose is riper but also has complex tertiary aromas that are very floral and loamy. Really so clear and vivid. So juicy and clean and wonderful finesse and unreal fruit. Maybe the best fruit out of all of these vintages. 9.5 to 9.6 overnight. — 3 years ago

Severn, Jay and 12 others liked this

Gut Hermannsberg

Hermannsberg GG Nahe Riesling 2018

Lyle Fass
9.6

Nose has the classic porphyry aromas and are just wonderful. It’s so expressive. Such mineral precision. Insane clarity of wet stone aromas. Nose is a bit quiet as well as it’s too cold. Palate is hauntingly elegant with unreal rockiness and sappy minerality. Not much fruit right now but the underlying architecture is perfect. Stunning purity. This is a rock star. Literally. What intense minerality on the finish but so so elegant. Just stunning. Some apricot now on the nose. Crystalline purity and just so well made and everything in its place. A stunner. — 4 years ago

Severn, Andrew and 9 others liked this

Domaine François Buffet

Volnay Pinot Noir 2023

Lyle Fass
9.4

Such an amazing village wine. Stunning wet earth and sappy mid-season cherries. Just so much aromatic lift and intensity. Unreal on the pop and pour. Gorgeous, tiny berried and very intense sweet fruit. Pure and balanced. Fresh and energetic. Velvety tannins and just terrific balance. So balanced I said it twice. Unbelievably delicious. — 6 months ago

Ray, Scott@Mister and 5 others liked this

Podere ai Valloni

Vigna Cristiana Boca Nebbiolo Blend 1999

Lyle Fass
9.6

Brilliant showing. So much energy and unreal inner mouth perfume. Nose is all roses and tar. Cherries will develop. Drinking perfectly. Huge concentration and depth. Awesome mid season cherry fruit and a terrific finish. — 7 months ago

Scott@Mister, Ira and 6 others liked this

Famille Jouffreau

Cuvée des Vignes Centenaires Cahors Malbec 2022

Lyle Fass
9.8

Oh man this is so good. On one of the final frigid nights of this year this is so hitting the spot. Young but so deep, so dark, so structured and so good. Insane nose. More details later. The opulence is unreal. Huge tannins and structure to go fifty. This is giving 47 Cheval Blanc. Oh. My. Fuck. What a palate. So rich, so much energy, black fruits, opulent. Just crazy. Old vines are strutting. 1884 or 1885. Just the sickest, purest black fruit ever. Same thing when tasting Desestret’s barrel of 140 year old Syrah. Black but opulent and refined. Same thing here. Palate is stoney and velvety wirh some thick blackberry and black current fruit. Unreal tannins on the finish. Nose is a drug now. 9.9. Outrageously black fruited, maybe even the most restrained anise ever. Deep, inner earth, minerality. Man. — 8 months ago

Jay, Zach and 12 others liked this
Jay Kline

Jay Kline Influencer Badge Premium Badge

🐶 how long has it been open?
Lyle Fass

Lyle Fass Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Jay Kline that was around 30 minutes but today it’s even better. Just incredible wine.
Jay Kline

Jay Kline Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Lyle Fass that’s my experience…they get even better

Domaine François Buffet

Clos des Chênes Volnay 1er Cru Pinot Noir 2023

Lyle Fass
9.8

Glory is this wine. Just one of the best wines in Burgundy now. After the 22 I had large expectations and this surpassed them. Nose is just bananas. Not literal bananas. The other type of bananas. The most complex cherry diaspora. Sour, mid season, late season and black. Spice galore and florals up the wazoo. Earth, limestone, dead leaves, living leaves and wet leaves. The nose is a 9.8 on the pop and pour. Just insane. Wild mint. What stands out the most is the layering and the clarity. Also the breadth. Wow that inner mouth perfume and endless, boundless energy that has the same fruit energy as La Tache. What I mean by that is this wine, yes can be about minerals as CDC is rocky, but man the fruit in 22 and now 23 is just in another register. Sappy, poised and clear as the sky is blue on a cloudless day. Yes the tannins are firm but you know with air they will melt into the fruit. The nobility of this site never fails to blow me away. Unreal concentration and density and just insane length. The tannins are velvety, sweet and intense but so so high class. Nose has so much florality, spice and red cherry fruit one cannot believe it. This is just insane. It’s almost a perfect wine. The balance is just beyond and the structure is incredible. This is a 50 year CDC. What a finish. Let’s see where this goes. After an hour the nose is remarkable. So deep, so nuanced, so spicy, so floral. Provocative. Palate is silky, sweet and so dense. Pumps the fruit out like an old set of Wilson Puppies. Unreal balance and purity. But this is built like a brick house. Let’s see where this goes. Will unfurl more but it’s a slow one! The concentration and tiny berry fruit intensity is off the charts. Now after 17 hours open its nose is full blown complex and flat out stunning. The cherry trifecta of sour/mid season and black. Mint and bramble plus wonderful and gorgeous sous bois. Stoney as well. All velvety bramble and such elegant and ripe tannin. A wave. Stunning inner mouth aromas, tiny berry fruit intensity and stunning purity. This seems like it’s more classic than the 22. Even on day 3 this is stunning. Lost nothing. — a year ago

Jay, Ron and 11 others liked this
Zach D

Zach D

Rather I’m going to drink one and age the others
Zach D

Zach D

2022 vintage
Lyle Fass

Lyle Fass Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Zach D 22 is stunning and drinking fine now.

Ziereisen

Rhini Blauer Spätburgunder 2020

Lyle Fass
9.6

Ridiculous Rhini! What a nose. Red cherries and berries galore. You can smell the density. Gorgeous soil and limestone tones. Unreal expansiveness and so so aromatic. Just a crazy nose that has so much breadth. The clarity, purity and pinosity are off the charts. Palate is tangy and tense and as usual at chez Ziereisen it needs mega air but the structural architecture is there. A very red fruited expression of Pinot which seems to be the new direction this estate’s Pinots are going in which I am here for. Lovely bitter herbals on the nose now. Great freshness and acidity but needs to fill out. It will. I’ll be back. Fruit getting sweeter with air that classic hidden Rhini structure. Now with air the nose is super spicy and complex . Herbal and spicey. Fruit is so much sweeter and is like a squeegee on the palate and clings to the palate. So clean on the backend. Huge quality change on day 2. Nose is denser and cleaner with rich cherry fruits, pine resin, black forest vibes and spice. Wow. A 9.7 nose today. Palate is elegant and dense with that unreal Rhini elegant yet substantial structure and crazy complexity. Big but very very fine tannins. 9.5 to 9.6 overnight. — 3 years ago

Severn, Pinotman and 7 others liked this