Casey Curbow

Sales Associate Windsor Wine Merchants

8.9

Green and full of funk. This bottle, while still recognizable as burgundy, never took flight or held an identity. — 6 years ago

Bob Colman

9.0

Easily mistaken for a shiraz. Disappointed at first but let it get heaps of air and it becomes a different wine — 7 years ago

Matt Sterr

9.0

Dry and earthy. — 8 years ago

with Alex

Fredrik Finn

9.2

Surprinsgly good, fresh and elegant, with a good complexity, showing a mix of fresh and dried red fruit, the tell tale soubouis and mineral notes gives this wine its well deserved identity. A nice development in the glass. Good balance and structure. At five years of age the wine drinks very well and is not in need of any further aging — 8 years ago

Michael Meyer

9.1

Super dry, crisp and precise. White flowers and lemon zest on the nose. Palate incorporates some nuttiness and salinity, and maybe a hint of stone fruits. Could easily be mistaken for a Chablis. — 9 years ago

Thomas Weber

9.3

Killer wine. I loved this. Macon Gamay grown on limestone if I'm not mistaken. Fresh red fruit on the nose and nervy palette with clean vibrant red fruit -cherries, cranberry, etc. 14€. — 9 years ago

Ron Siegel

9.6

Killer btl of this. This La Mish is still showing young but so good. No mistaken this wine. — 9 years ago

Iwan

9.1

Could be mistaken for a Trousseau from Jura, but maybe a little fresher and more fruit forward. Well done! — 6 years ago

Peter Wassam

9.1

A wild identity. Tamarind and flower and spice — 6 years ago

Hum

8.9

Almost mistaken for Nebbiolo so tar and leather laced. Floral elements muted. Fruit is primary on the palate. — 8 years ago

Marc Melser

9.1

We had this on 1/30-31/18. A really good well balanced, full bodied wine with a smooth finish. Tastes of dark fruit and violets. Could be mistaken for a CA Cab. — 8 years ago

Mark Flesher

9.5

Found this one behind another one in storage. All I can say is....DAMN. This drinks like a Sangiovese that I paid 3x the amount for. Dense cedar and a little sweet blackberry. Smooth operator on the front and finish. A part of me is very sad this one was bought out by Kendall Jackson but I hope they kept their identity intact. Lilac and pepper finish. Immense. LOVED this wine. Almost gave it 95 but not quite there. I wish I had another case of this one! — 9 years ago

Bob McDonald

9.6

A reminder that these were all tasted blind and as it turned out the fabled Romanee Conti was first. My notes - Lovely sexy nose of violets. Ripe yet restrained - aristocratic. Minerally, savoury with an incredible long finish. Fine tannins but will blossom. Actually my least pointed wine in the 6 Vosne Romanee Grand Crus. I'm sure it would not have been had I known its identity! — 9 years ago

Fred Calatayud

9.2

Pleasantly surprised by this Merlot - could have easily mistaken it as a cab. Strong, but nicely balanced dark fruit with a long finish. It still had a lot in the tank given the 2007 vintage. If you are sitting on this, you may start drinking it now, but it can go longer. — 9 years ago

Evan Bienstock

9.4

This could be mistaken for Cote de Nuits very easily. Fruit, oak, tannin, alcohol all in harmony at year 7. Very balanced and pretty! More please. — 6 years ago

Raj Harb

9.6

Fantastic wine. A lead pencil and green note that I probably would’ve mistaken for old cab franc if tasted blind. Really strong showing. — 7 years ago

Alexander Vadas

9.3

Mistaken for n. Rhone — 8 years ago

with Mathew and Stephen

Chris McClellan

9.0

Wow, loved this. Black/red fruits, raisinated, baked, fruits, no new oak, high booze, medium plus tannins and medium acid. Paired great with bbq chicken. I could have mistaken for amarone/ripasso, but this likely has more tannin. Well balanced. Need more! — 8 years ago

Alex

9.0

Old world. Little bit of leather and tobacco and with some earthy funk to it. Once it opened up, lots of dark fruit and cola. Could have mistaken for Italian. — 9 years ago

Bob McDonald

9.7

Dark ruby - almost Opaque. Colour of an Aussie Shiraz. Lovely perfume. Powerful palate with incredible depth and intensity. Ripe fruit. Everything there for a long life. Much surprise when the identity was revealed as a Charmes with many thinking it was the Dugat Py Mazis. — 9 years ago