Reed H Whitman

9.2

Unbelievable Christmas wine for the festivities…. — 4 years ago

Alexandre Pagliano

9.2

Very dark rubi robe, no signs of 18 year old. From a half bottle which is remarquable. Notes of flowers and spices, medium bodied, balanced, great acidity and fruit. One of the last vintages before JF Mugnier took it back. Great stuff ! — 5 years ago

with Adriana

Gor

9.3

Super well balanced burgundy Chardonnay where oak meets acidity at exactly the right spot. Citrus, white peach, hint of butter on the nose. Long finish. Good stuff — 7 years ago

Christophe Lamy

9.1

Light cherry red. Fat medium running tears. Cherry black currant first now, light almond or another savoury note there. Long finish long finish. Discernable whole cluster tannins tannins. Medium acid — 7 years ago

Fraser McKinley

9.2

A little shy and closed up but tasty nonetheless- 2010 — 9 years ago

Neil Cornish

9.1

A little cheesy on the nose, but in a good way. Potpourri. Good acid spine. Cleans up and brightens with a little air. Red fruits and spice develop. — 10 years ago

with Jon, Jon and 1 other

M. Ventre

9.1

2012. Spice spice and everything nice.. Balanced, fine texture, clean finish — 11 years ago

Stephanie Wu

9.5

Light oak and buttery nose. Good minerality. Well rounded, good mouth feel. Had this at le Bernadin. — 5 years ago

with Tim

Ron Siegel

9.4

Great blind tasting today of 2 rare 15 NSG’s both showed lots of ripe black cherry, sweet spices with good mineral & acidity — 6 years ago

Michael Egan

9.3

2017 young and full of power and grace — 7 years ago

Raj Harb

9.4

Fantastic. Jumps out of the glass with a woodsy waft. Powerful and dark toned but manages to remain lifted. — 8 years ago

Kim Schott Jones Watt

9.6

Lovely wine. Corals with earthy tones, mineral finish. — 8 years ago

Colin Nuckolls

9.1

Silky smooth. A lot going on in this one. Truly extraordinary for the money! Lovely — 10 years ago

Michael Cruz

9.0

CUT 45 Park Lane — 12 years ago

Ted

9.5

I have been digging the Rhone wines I have had recently. Really good now. Has almost an earthy base before some nice ripe berry fruit starts showing. — 5 years ago

with Jeni

Ron Siegel

9.2

This was elegant & floral with good spice showing notes of cherry, dried herbs & rose petal, — 6 years ago

Aleksandar Pesko

9.5

Rich and beautifully balanced — 6 years ago

David L

9.5

05’ Simply outstanding! — 7 years ago

with Mike

Limor Finkel

9.4

Still a baby. This is a wine that gives me goosebumps thinking about what it will become over the next decade or two. Holiday party lunch for the win! — 9 years ago

Doc Jay

9.3

Allen Meadows says 94/100. A bit generous me thinks. Weighty. @Stephen Osgood you mad or naw? — 10 years ago