Ron Siegel

9.4

1st time drinking his white. Nice inner core of stone fruits & citrus, but bone dry on the finish. Love the balance & finish of this. Nice surprise! — 8 years ago

Bob McDonald

9.7

Dark ruby - almost Opaque. Colour of an Aussie Shiraz. Lovely perfume. Powerful palate with incredible depth and intensity. Ripe fruit. Everything there for a long life. Much surprise when the identity was revealed as a Charmes with many thinking it was the Dugat Py Mazis. — 9 years ago

Ted

9.8

Terra cotta orange/red in color. Cedar and tart cherry. So much sediment but worth the effort in decanting. — 10 years ago

Erik McLaughlin

Vice President Seven Hills Winery

9.3

1999 Dugat-Py Gevry 1er from mag. In a perfect place now. Ripe and opulent but with secondary components emerging. — 11 years ago

Jeremy Shanker

Sommelier at RN74

8.9

Vosne on steroids — 8 years ago

with Eddy

Jorge Henriquez

Zachys Wine Auctions

9.4

This is absolutely gorgeous. Full, rich, almonds, roasted apple. A bit of creaminess on the mid palate with beautiful acidity throughout. — 9 years ago

Somm David T

Independent Sommelier/Wine Educator

9.3

Rich raspberries, cherries, mid minerality, awesome fruit. This will require patience. It's at least a 10 year hold. Barrel tasting the 14's with Ms. Dugat. — 9 years ago

Harley Carbery

Director of Wine, Mandalay Bay Resort & Casino and Delano Las Vegas

9.5

2007. Big, decanted an hour in advance and it still needed more. — 10 years ago

Ryan Mullins

9.8

Louis ck would approve of the use of amazing when referring to this wine! — 11 years ago

Fredybeans

9.3

Noir
Nez fume cerise noire orange sanguine et irradiant
Bouche suave et ample avec un boisé cet present mais portant le vin dense et race
Finale sur le jus de fruit orange sanguine et fruit rouge tanin délicat après 24 h d ouverture — 9 years ago

with El

Stan W

9.6

Popcorn nose in the right way, butterscotch, salty cold stone mineralality. Good use of wood. — 9 years ago

with Josh and Phil

David J Kasper

10

Incredible power, nice mix of black and red fruits with a lingering finish of 45+ seconds. A true gem. — 10 years ago

Riccardo Sgarra

9.1

Fresh great roundness — 10 years ago