Tom Casagrande

9.1

Shy nose is coming on with air: honeysuckle flowers, dried apricot, very high-toned minerality. So dry in the mouth. Intensely mineral. Long and pure. Not a friendly wine though. More like demanding. Not sure that makes sense. Can't wait to see what it's like tomorrow.

Night 2: nose is all fruit: golden plums and lightly grilled peach with a faint citrus peel note. Fruit and minerals on the palate, with an unusual foursquare feel. Minerals minerals on the finish. All in a light-bodied, dry frame. Very distinctive. — 9 years ago

with Lyle

Jimmy Hayes

Estate Director Mayacamas Vineyard

8.9

The 08 from the night before was more interesting. This was clean and racy but a bit foursquare. Still tasty. — 10 years ago

Brett Jones

9.4

Mid ruby. Black cherry, oak, dry, robust tannins, dark chocolate, dark red fruit, taut with foursquare richness. Long finish. #WestSicilyWine — 12 years ago

Doctor No

9.3

Drinking beautifully. The fruit is still very present and the acidity dance-on-your-tongue lively. There's a certain clarity and straightforwardness that makes me think of Old California, along with almost old-Rioja notes of tobacco and toasted spices but maybe a bit more foursquare. Tannins soft but still providing body and a reasonably long finish. — 9 years ago

Rory Parness

9.1

Foursquare yacht club — 10 years ago

Matté

Manager The Wine Cellars

8.9

Classic Prüm closed nose of wet wool mixed with tropical fruit. Plenty of wet match stick sulphur, always reminds me of a swirling mix of sweet papaya and shandy bass but with plenty of clear complexity to come. In the mouth it's fairly foursquare at the mo but has plenty of promise, well defined apple & lime fruit but really needs another 5-10 years in the cellar to shine — 11 years ago

Keith Levenberg

9.5

Almost jarring the contrast, coming to this after the Rouget - so much structure and scaffolding in this one, fortunately without being foursquare. Nice contrast of blue and black berry fruit in here. With its muscle, it feels more Morey than Chambolle - this would be at home next to a Clos de la Roche, for example. — 10 years ago

with Amy

Rory Parness

9.4

Foursquare yacht club — 10 years ago

Brett Jones

8.9

Deep ruby, violets, brambly cherries, dry, rounded tannins. Herbal spicy black fruit with a spicy, foursquare finish. — 12 years ago