JJ Lumia

9.0

Tangerine, lemon, and mineral notes. Very steely and gravelly, but not offensively so. Impressive this has held up. — 8 years ago

Patch Manning

9.5

Must decant/air for 3+ hrs.
Opens up to a sumptuous wine. Dark plum coloured. Earthen nose. Leather, must, dried violets but with subtle blue berries. Fantastic mouth feel. New world with forward fruits heavy and rich. Vanilla, licorice and cola. Medium plus tannins. Would not pair with rich meat or steak. Hard and semi-hard cheese should be good. — 9 years ago

Gabby costanzo

9.7

Unexpected lunch with benefits — 9 years ago

Erin Pooley

Owner/Winemaker Good Luck Wines

10

Perfect and classic — 10 years ago

Molly

9.0

Smells like winter ❄️ menthol, apple, toasty, creamy, touch of honey on the nose. The taste lemongrass, rose petal... Gives you a silky tongue 🌹😛 — 11 years ago

John O'Hara

9.4

Venge... Plumpjack site. Drinking great... — 11 years ago

Leslie Fresco

10

Amazing wine! — 8 years ago

Bob McDonald

9.2

Won the Trophy for Best Shiraz at the National Wine Show 2012. Fruit from the Gundagai region and starting to put this region on the map. Peppery red fruits and starting to develop some leather notes at 7 years. A nice counterpoint to the lush Barossa styles showing the versatility of Shiraz. — 9 years ago

Benjamin Hickey

9.0

2009 showing some nice age flavours. — 9 years ago

Rachel Ginn

9.0

Nice basic Chardonnay. A little bubbly not a lot though — 10 years ago

Ramon R

9.1

Strong cherries — 10 years ago

Karen Holmes

9.3

Pleasantly surprised at the quality of this $13 (at HEB) Pinot. Can easily play with the big boys. Fruity but not sweet. Paired well with salmon and beef. Versatile. — 11 years ago

Heath Little

9.5

All class and will only get better with time — 12 years ago

Richard Edwards

10

Perfectly aged. Kerosine on the nose. Perfectly balanced. — 8 years ago

Sammie GoDeep Robert

9.1

Wow. Dry, clean and right on time! — 9 years ago

Scott Taddeo

9.2

Real good. Talc, floral, lemon grass, grapefruit and lime. Lengthy in the palate, slight phenolic grip along with a saltyness all providing some real interest — 9 years ago

James Gourley

9.3

Was a 9.2 yesterday, but after sitting overnight it definitely improved. The wood seems more integrated and the whole thing is more vibrant. Nice balance of fruit and earth. I'll hang on to my other bottle of this for awhile. — 9 years ago

Steve The Wine Guy

Cellarbrations at Cottesloe Western Australia, Certified Specialist of Wine (CSW)

9.6

Excellent, looks great. Should have a long life ahead. — 10 years ago

Pierpaolo Petrassi MW

Master of Wine; Head of Beer, Wine & Spirits Waitrose

9.1

2005. A house favourite and one of the best expressions of New World Riesling which exists. The late release adds both a great story but the required time to make this superb wine really sing. — 11 years ago

Jenny Duffy

9.8

Heavy Chardonnay. Very buttery. From Bin 608 in Baltimore — 12 years ago