Brilliant Mistake Wines

Louis Roederer

Cristal Brut Champagne Chardonnay Pinot Noir Blend 1990

Delectable Wine
9.7

The 1990 Cristal is remarkable. Polished, nuanced and light on its feet, the 1990 is all class. Citrus, orchard fruit and floral notes are wonderfully lifted throughout. A slight reductive note adds character on the finely knit finish. I can’t think of a better way to start this tasting. Simply put, the 1990 is a total rock star. Moreover, it is much more delicate than most wines from this ripe vintage. Amazingly, the 1990 tastes like it is still not ready! “Nineteen ninety was my second vintage here,” says Chef de Caves Jean-Baptiste Lécaillon. “It was ideal. The fruit was just perfect. We blocked the malolactic fermentation completely and only fermented 6-7% of our lots in oak, as opposed to the more typical 20%, in order to preserve as much freshness as possible. The wine was made by my predecessor, Michel Pansu, but I was learning. This was the first year I started working with oxygen by reducing sulfites in vinification to pre-oxidize the Chardonnay musts, as I do know, which allows me to get rid of all the unstable, oxidative compounds. With Pinot, on the other hand, you need a little bit of sulfur at crush or you lose the brilliant fruit. (Antonio Galloni, Vinous, December 2018) — 7 years ago

Marqués de Murrieta

Castillo Ygay Gran Reserva Especial Rioja Tempranillo Blend 2007

Cherry, dried fruit, oak, silky, smooth tannins, brilliant. — 8 years ago

Ron, David and 1 other liked this

Brilliant Mistake Wines

Taylor Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2014

The second year of this great wine. '14 yielded twice the production of '13 and expanded from Stags Leap to Rutherford. This resulted in a RP rating of 94 pt. Congratulations John and Stacey. Dark berries with hints of cocoa, tobacco and cinnamon. Adding to my collection! — 8 years ago

Frank ADAM STROMFELDJoe Lucca
with Frank, ADAM and 2 others
Kevin, ADAM and 17 others liked this
Kevin Ortzman

Kevin Ortzman Influencer Badge

Well said, my friend!

Two Hands

Brilliant Disguise Barossa Valley Moscato 2012

I'm not a huge sweet moscato fan, so this one works perfectly for me. Loved it! Just a touch of effervescence. — 9 years ago

Joe Soldezzo
with Joe
Joe liked this

Azienda Agricola Fontodi

Flaccianello della Pieve Colli Toscana Centrale Sangiovese 2007

Six hours and quadruple decanted and it's brilliant — 11 years ago

Château d'Yquem

Sauternes Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend 1989

Lemon creme brûlée in a bottle, with more acidity than I would have predicted 20 years ago. For a long time this was my third favorite of the brilliant 1988 to 1990 run, but it may have passed the 1990 and is closing in on the 1988 as the balancing acidity becomes more and more apparent. — 7 years ago

Kevin WoodsStan W
with Kevin and Stan
Mark, Giancarlo and 17 others liked this

Jean Foillard

Cuvée 3.14 Morgon Gamay 2013

So silky, whiff of Brett blows off quickly to reveal pure and bright black cherry fruit. Brilliant — 7 years ago

Severn, Mark and 15 others liked this
Severn Goodwin

Severn Goodwin Influencer Badge Premium Badge

One of my fav Foillard bottles, and the '13 is awesome!

Jérôme Prévost

La Closerie Les Béguines Extra Brut Champagne Pinot Meunier

Lime and limestone. So savory. Brilliant acidity. Great with petrale sole. — 8 years ago

Paul liked this

Brilliant Mistake Wines

Stags Leap Cabernet Sauvignon

Each time I have this 13 I like it more and more. Shared with family who hadn't tried it before and they also loved it. The finish on this is long and focused just love it. — 9 years ago

David liked this

Azienda Agricola Le Ragnaie

Brunello di Montalcino Sangiovese 2009

It was the best Italian wine I have ever had. Brilliant. Excellent depth and tannins. — 10 years ago

Weingut Keller

Hubacker Riesling 2010

Infanticide, I know... brilliant nevertheless — 10 years ago

Screaming Eagle

Oakville Cabernet Sauvignon

Chelli Webster
9.6

'92 screaming eagle- sensational noise jammy black currants and oak-full body ripe intense fruit- brilliant finish — 11 years ago

john&stacy and Greg liked this
Greg Gregory

Greg Gregory Influencer Badge

Always my favorite Screagle of all time.

Nikolaihof

Vinothek Wachau Riesling 1997

Finessed, terrific complexity, bruised white peach, petrol, wet stone and a bit nutty along with tea leaves on the finish. Such a brilliant expression of Wachau. — 7 years ago

Ira and Weijie liked this

Tenuta dell'Ornellaia

Bolgheri Red Bordeaux Blend 1988

Brilliant plum and raspberry with as smooth a lasting impression as a Teddy Pendegrass tune. No acidic overtones. — 7 years ago

Joseph C BurkeJanna Burke
with Joseph C and Janna
Joseph C Burke

Joseph C Burke

The 1988 still shows an intoxicating nose of violet, sandalwood and spice; on the palate there is soft and generous ripe fruit (dark plum, black raspberry), a hint of herbs and licorice, although not as powerful and primary as it once was; notes of sweet tobacco and bittersweet chocolate lace the very fine tannins through a long finish. I judge this to be slightly past its prime compared to my notes for previous bottles from the case. 93/100 on 7/7/2018.

Krug

Grande Cuvée Brut Champagne Blend

Somm David T
9.4

Bruised golden apple, pineapple, golden raisins, ginger ale, brioche, citrus blend, touch of honey, yellow lilies, quince, orange peel, nut skin, toffee, brilliant acidity, chalkiness and rich long finish. — 8 years ago

"Odedi", Eric and 12 others liked this

Thomas

Dundee Hills Pinot Noir 2008

A brilliant wine from my favorite Oregon winery. — 10 years ago

Doug and Tom liked this
Doug Burress

Doug Burress Influencer Badge

Excellent!

Egon Müller

Scharzhofberger Kabinett Riesling

Heavenly! Crushed rock, citrus, white flowers, hint of petrol. I can't stop putting my nose in the glass. Bright, juicy red apple and melon flavors. Medium bottle with sugar kept in check by brilliant acidity. Finish sails on for a minute plus. Truly one of the best! — 10 years ago

Steve liked this