Jeff Loo

9.2

Out of Magnum. Wanted to see what was aging better, 2016 Burgundy or my son that just turned 2. Jury still out! This was however, very good. For a young burg from a producer than requires age, it had a delicate side that expressed itself well with amazing density and structure. A real good start to a long life ahead. Glad I have more mags. — 7 years ago

Paul Woolls

9.0

Jeff Fontanella makes this to show a particular barrel manufacturer. Fun. — 8 years ago

Scott Rowe

9.4

Solid Cab no matter the occasion. Worth the asking price though? The jury is still out on that one. — 8 years ago

Christine Havens

8.9

On a quest to find the perfect wine to pair with Pho, I picked up this lively Lambrusco from Kermit Lynch...two years ago. I found it while moving around bottles, happily, though the jury is still out as to the pairing. My beef bone broth is still reducing as I type this. As to the wine, it's ruby-hued, slightly cloudy and appropriately spritzy. Plums and figs conjoin earth and decaying rose petal. There's plenty of tannic bite, with firm structure and a pleasant herbaceous leesy, if brief, finish. — 8 years ago

Jody Scharf

9.4

Delicious. 2011 bad year ,? Not from this jury of my peers. ! Red bell pepper, black cherry, and dried herbs with a touch of jalapeno. Tannins linger with a nice dark deep red color. Nose of dark fruits. Here's to you Palmer@Palmer Emmitt — 9 years ago

Neal Krishna Devaraj

9.5

Jury duty. Lunch break — 9 years ago

erto l

9.7

thinking this was the 2014 reserve release.... it's unico and me likey unico. jury still out for me on whether or not the blending to achieve the house style is the way to go. had some lesser vintages that reservations beat but also some killer single vintages that smoke the reserva. all about the dirt and those great vintages are the ones that have it. — 10 years ago

thomas huston

9.2

brutal ? jury is out.
delicious ? for. sure. — 7 years ago

Ryan Vento

9.2

If there was one redeeming thing that took place today (i.e. The day I got selected as a juror) it was that my Burgundy stems arrived. Cheers to immediately putting them to good use and to the commencement of 42 hours of Jury Duty 😵 — 7 years ago

with Krystal

Mike Saviage

9.2

Light straw gold color. Nice weight in the glass. Citrus nose with notes of honeydew, spice and some gravel stone. Surprisingly fat and rich in the mouth. Ok finish. Lacking the strong acidity spine I was expecting. Not sure what to make of this.... will it get better with more age, is it in an awkward phase, will it improve with more air... the jury is out. — 8 years ago

Rob Brobst III

9.4

Wow @Paul T this one is full bodied. Dark candied cherries, and an overload of tar, pencil lead and black fruit. The label says Pinot but the jury is out on that. — 9 years ago

Bob McDonald

9.0

Fair to say the jury is still out on whether Shiraz works in the northern part of Margaret River but this is very good. Plummy with a hint of butterscotch (oak) and touch of black pepper. Medium bodied - fleshy with softening tannins. Short term cellaring. Very satisfying. — 9 years ago

Cynthia

9.4

Very nice but have recently returned to white. So the jury is still out. — 10 years ago

Scott Rowe

9.3

Colleen’s Block Pinot Noir.
$200 Pinot? The jury is out. — 7 years ago

Stephen Dodson

9.2

Pretty fancy and jury is out. Initial nose like burnt rubber, but after an hour mellowed into deliciousness. Guests have now left and have half a bottle left + good cheese - result!!!

Finished it - bloody lovely — 7 years ago

Cathy Corison

Owner/Winemaker Corison Winery

9.3

Delicious break from jury duty. Delicious. — 8 years ago

Gordon L

9.1

Wound up but showing tropical fruits in the nose. Advanced color, but has some nice material. Gun metal nose after several hours. Jury is still out. — 8 years ago

Scott Rowe

9.1

The Big Boys Grenache!!
Deep and dark.
$80 though? Jury is out. — 9 years ago

Sipping Fine Wine

8.9

The jury is out as of now for this wine. My current tasting of this private label, Caymus produced Cab, shows aromas of ripe dark fruit and herb notes. On the palate, cherry, blackberry and sweet currant flavors with hints of cacao and earthy bramble tones. Fully developed tannins on the smooth finish. Caymus wines are noted for being approachable while young, but will 1858 stand up with some time? May be a little pricy at $50. I will check back with 1858 in a few years. Tasting Sample. — 9 years ago

Adam Hirsch

10

Doesn't get better than this. Not like any Chardonnay you've ever had. — 10 years ago