Anjanette Pelletier

9.7

Very smooth and rich. Limited peat and cinnamon. — 10 years ago

with Myke and Sarah

David Kline

8.9

Root beer nose with pine sap tendrils, caraway seed, carmelized coffee and tea biscuit, and rosemary. Tastes of pine nettle, peppercorn, brine and caramel smoke. — 10 years ago

Craig Benner

8.9

Tasty scotch! — 10 years ago

Lauren Young

8.9

Strong, but nuanced caramel, at first, then a punch in the face on the end. In a good way — 11 years ago

Dave Harris

9.3

Macallan 12. Great integration of caramel and peat. — 11 years ago

Ryan Mullins

9.3

Signatory macallan 17yr cask strength — 12 years ago

William Meyers

9.6

Macallan Fine&Rare 1988 23 46.7% cask 12203 American oak produces loads of vanilla & a liberal dusting of cinnamon w/freshly cut green apples culminating with a long finish over charred cedar - a Rare treat! — 12 years ago

Corey Henson

9.4

Mmm, scotch get in my belly. This 10 yr. is so smooth! — 12 years ago

Blake Seidler

10

Waco, Tx January 2013 — 13 years ago

Nicola Morvillo

9.7

Cena bologma eccelso samaroli — 13 years ago

Anjanette Pelletier

9.6

Director's Edition - classic Macallan profile with a nice smooth taste — 10 years ago

with Myke and Sarah

Frank L

9.5

Was a great way to end the evening. — 10 years ago

with Mick

Ashlee Howarth

9.3

A little post-defense scotch for our buddy McQuirk — 10 years ago

Weizhi TAN

10

Perfect 10. Doesn't get better. — 11 years ago

Stefanie Jackson

10

Wonderful! fine tobacco, coffee and toasted nuts. Smooth and polished.
— 11 years ago

Rob Bear

10

The crucial element in the best Rusty Nail I've ever had. — 12 years ago

Ludwig Louw

9.6

One of the best Single Malts! — 12 years ago

Perry Lee

9.6

Quite possibly the best scotch I've ever tried. Rich and complex flavors. Hints of caramel, smoke, spice. Awesome!! Highly recommended if you can find a bottle. — 12 years ago

Guy Yalif

9.6

Testing comments — 13 years ago

Jaching Huang

9.7

A really really REALLY good scotch! — 13 years ago

with Eric

JKT

9.3

Beautiful nose of flowers and cream. Dark color. Great body of complexity with long finish. Almost fruity. 1998 17yr. Sherry solera cask in 1970. Gordon's tasting 8/25/16 special scotch. 43% ABV. — 10 years ago

Veronica Castro

9.2

Macallan Edition No 2 El Celler De Can Roca - highly sippable with toffee, wood, vanilla, citrus, and marmalade notes. Thoroughly delicious. — 10 years ago

S.B

9.2

Essential. — 10 years ago

Wesley Keppel-Henry

10

Warm, oaky , hint of vanilla aroma. Major vanilla flavor the whole sip through. Pretty smooth, still a bit of bite. Butterscotch! Super loooong finish. — 11 years ago

Dave Harris

9.6

Macallan 18 year. Cubs win. — 11 years ago

with Nick

Riccardo L.

9.2

Caramel brittle on the nose, very light at first and explodes into a crescendo of subtle flavours -- vanilla and spice. Long and complicated finish. The taste just seems to grow infinitely after you've swallowed. — 12 years ago

William Meyers

9.6

Macallan Fine&Rare 1988 23 46.7% cask 12203 American oak produces loads of vanilla & a liberal dusting of cinnamon w/freshly cut green apples culminating with a long finish over charred cedar - a Rare treat! — 12 years ago

Andrew Stueve

9.7

Very nice cask strength scotch. Have to rate it as good as Macallan Cask Strength. — 12 years ago

William Moy

9.5

1991 Samaroli “Macallan” Selezione — 13 years ago

Martin West

9.6

Not quite wine but brilliant just the same — 13 years ago