Bonnie Chu

9.0

Bright yellow, almost neon. Jolly rancher and a lil sulphuric. Rich honey on the palate. P&M from France. — 8 years ago

Bonnie Chu

9.2

Jeff's 🎂🥃...Thanks p&m! — 8 years ago

with Paul

B

9.0

2009 Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey Chevalier Montrachet. Holiday dinner w McC and M at Il P. We think it has prem-ox issue. Got better as it sat in the glass, but not the best version of this wine we've had. — 8 years ago

B

10

1990 Joseph Faiveley Latricieres Chambertin. Lunch w M at Il P. We got faked out at first by bad glasses, but once we switched out, nose was completely different. Beautiful brick color, nose was sweet, forest floor, mineral. This wine kept getting better throughout lunch. It really evolved and got more rounded with time. We ended up really liking this wine a lot. — 9 years ago

David J. H. Ruiz

10

3/20/2016: Anniv Chloe (3 y) P/M — 9 years ago

linda sakane

9.1

Loved this white blend. Light delight! And awesome label if you are into S&M or bondage.
:p — 10 years ago

with Raymond and Masae

Jessica G

9.0

N: musty and oaky, dark fruit cherry and baking spice, black pepper P: delicious, smooth, low acid M/3-/M — 10 years ago

with Neil

Kyle Sheffield

9.0

Great minerality and fruit flavors. P&M love it — 10 years ago

Sybaritewino C.Lawrence

9.2

lovely sherry notes with bubbles and finesse — 11 years ago

Andrew Benn

9.1

Puligny-Montrachet
Had glass at David Toutain and it surpassed the Pacalet 2009 P-M that we had that night — 11 years ago

Scott Wren

9.0

Orchard blossom with lemony minerality Slightly sharp for P-M. — 8 years ago

Ian Burrows

Sommelier Atelier Crenn

9.5

Structured and perfumed in the richer style (for P-M) and thus tastes akin to Meursault. — 8 years ago

with Ann

Nesim Bekalti

9.5

Raw meat, slight rubber, blackberry jam, pencil shavings, slight barnyard (N) Black fig, ripe cherries, raspberry, black licorice, cocoa powder, allspice. (P). BOMBA! Med silky tannins, m+ acid, long finish. Like a cross btw Burgundy and CA Pinot! — 9 years ago

David J. H. Ruiz

9.5

4/1/2016: Bilt (Laurent, Laeti, P, M) — 9 years ago

David J. H. Ruiz

9.5

3/25/2016: Bbq Tuna (P, M) — 9 years ago

Paul Sowerby

8.9

BD. tastes real and authentic and pure thanks M & P — 10 years ago

Neil Rudis

8.9

N: Raspberry, white pepper, baking spice, moist clay soil. P: Bright fruit, jammy, mild tannins, balanced L+/3+/M — 10 years ago

with Jessica

Nesim Bekalti

9.0

Lees, cream, pyrazines (gr bell p, grassy), amarena, cherry lifesaver, plum, fragoline di bosco, slight Mon Cheri; med + phenolics (raspy tongue).

Tastes like a cross between Champagne and a light Cab Fr. Amazing w duck/bacon/orange zest pâté!!
Def food wine. Use in place of light red! — 10 years ago

Pam Woolf

10

Party with P, A , M, O, Sh
Aged excellent — 11 years ago

Cecilie Isern

9.3

God rødvin - bryllupsdag m+p 2014 — 11 years ago

Scott Wren

8.9

Super fresh app key pear flavors. A bit steely for me for P-M. — 8 years ago

Alan Weinberg

9.2

damn—forgot how good P-Y C-M did in 2010. Intense essence of Chardonnay, like boiling down a gallon of wine into a few ounces, tastebuds are in shock. The concentration and balance of this wine are stunning. Great stuff—and just a St. Aubin! — 8 years ago

B

9.5

2000 Bruno Giacosa Riserva Asili di Barbaresco. Holiday dinner w McC and M at Il P. Really good for most of the bottle- a little sweetness, a little funk. K was pleasantly surprised how enjoyable it was, despite its youth. Only thing to note was that the very last bit of wine that had been sitting in the glass was completely flat when we came back around to it ~45 min later. — 8 years ago

Kurt-Inge Eklund

9.3

Showing P-M characteristics very well. — 9 years ago

David J. H. Ruiz

9.5

4/1/2016: Bilt (Laurent, Laeti, P, M) — 9 years ago

James Parker Huston, CWE

Sommelier Charlie Palmer

9.0

Very complex with tons of fruit left. Over delivered. Called 1976 Zinfandel. — 9 years ago

Michael Brown

9.3

Amazing Sinsky at M&P #wine — 10 years ago

B

10

1996 Falletto do Bruno Giacosa Barbaresco. Drank at lunch w K, M, P&R at Il P. Awesome. This was so good! Super smooth and balanced with great mouthfeel. Loved it. Total fave — 10 years ago

Vivian Wang

10

Dinner with M&P — 11 years ago

Jordan Mackay

Wine Editor San Francisco Magazine

9.9

About as great as M-P (and Chardonnay) can get. Much like Shaq or Lady Gaga, it gained heft and authority over time. — 12 years ago