Honestly, not bad. Especially for the price. Don’t look for the world, though; but if you’re expecting a small town, you’ll be pleasantly surprised. — 6 years ago
Here is an example of a 98 you have taste so you don't jump to the conclusion that there were no good 98's made in Napa. Is this their best Martha's, no, but for the price it's selling at today...it's a pretty good value for this wine. Ready to go. Not sure how much better it's going to get but it still has a fair amount of life left...8-10 more years. Blackberries, black plum, dark cherries, Christmas cake, spice-box, eucalyptus, dry red floral, elegant soft minerals with crush rocks, tobacco leaf, nice acidity and finish. Delicious. — 10 years ago

Paul T, Missing My Beautiful Wife 24/7
I was just about to comment on the 98's in general, I bought a case of 96 standard Cabernet back when they were released from a wine shop, drank most of them too early, but 1 bottle was sitting on the bottom of my rack that I didn't see for about 10 years, it was perfect, all tannins had disappeared & smooth as silk,
Paul T, Missing My Beautiful Wife 24/7
@David Trumper wasn't Marthas just replanted because of disease in 94 or 95?Lots of cigar box and barnyard brett going on. Very much about non fruit. — 10 years ago
Tobacco, cigar box, roast meat , drinking nicely — 11 years ago
bbq beef, cigar, burnt leather, log, wood box. — 12 years ago
This wine makes me happy. Can we say value extraordinaire. I've never heard anyone say anything but good things about this blend - especially after I show them what it is. Sure it's in a box but so will you be at one point. Get over it. It's decent - no - damn good wine. — 12 years ago
Absolutely worth it — 13 years ago
Expressive, enticing, aetheric.
Dusty cherries, tobacco leaf, leather, (very) dark chocolate, wood finish, a hint of cigar box. So fresh, so uplifting, so youthful!
On the palate amazing purity, zingy cherry acidity, a hint of orange peel, present, juicy yet very, very fine tannins. After a few hours this shows a darker, richer side. Really nice flow and great energy!
Brilliant, just brilliant. And amazing vale, for this quality! — 5 years ago
A lighter style Grenache from the Vale with high acidity and a touch of spice to finish. — 7 years ago
Great taste. Not dry. Smooth with a hint of blackberry. Ideally paired with a medium rare steak. — 10 years ago
Cigar box, Leather and meats. Very ready and delicious. A Burgundian Gruaud. — 10 years ago
1996 vintage. Medium ruby hue with some bricking around the rim. On the palate, alluring concentrated aromas of cedar, cigar box, tobacco leaf, ripe black plums, Earth and leather. Sweet spice and old oak. Mature. On the palate, medium acidity, medium tannins - ripe and integrated, medium alcohol. Good concentration of flavours. Medium plus finish. Slight astringency on the finish. Really rather good although wood dominant! Drink now until 2020+ — 11 years ago
Classic La Mish that is still showing young despite its 33 yrs of age. Black fruits, smoke, cigar box, and fruit cake, large structured with medium weight. — 11 years ago
I love this when I'm in the mood for something slightly robust but not sweet. It's also not incredibly dry- a really great wine!! — 13 years ago
Dunn was a producer I purchased every year when I 1st visited the valley. This wine is still youthful with many years ahead showing an old school style with a perfumed nose of mostly black fruits, cedar, earth, leather, lead, spice box & tobacco leaf. A beautiful wine that you wish all Cali wines would be like at 30 yrs of age. — 5 years ago
Loved this leggy, rich, berryful wine. Very smooth and delicious. 2015 vintage on 9/2019. — 7 years ago
Wine in a box extravaganza #budgetdrinking the box wine at which the bar is set. Deep, big, moderate spice, strong berry flavors, but not sweet — 9 years ago
Ruby with faint reddish brick rims. Great color. Nose of black cherries, warm fruit, mocha and cedar box. In the mouth, very round and captivating. Long finish. The 97 is in a good spot right now. — 11 years ago
I could have had the whole bottle myself, unfortunately I had to share, LOL. Fruity with the taste of plums, some blackberry and even a tiny bit of a chocolate hit. It tasted really good on the palette. — 11 years ago
An enticing wine bursting with flavors of dark berry fruits, licorice and spice. — 12 years ago
Izola had this 12 years ago
Classic #Rioja style all the way! This folks is how you do it right! A Plush spice box of flavor, round and harmonious, cocoa, underbrush and old leather stained with dried cherries. La Rioja Alta is one of my top five favorite producers in Rioja! — 13 years ago
Mike Saviage

Taken to Merrimans in Waimea on the Big Island. Darkish tawny, not quite opaque. Notes of black cherry, tobacco leaf, cedar, plums, cigar box and some spice. Super silky. Paired perfectly with my ribeye. The waiter said it best, “Oooh… Yummy!” — 4 years ago