Matthew Cohen

9.4

Like if Willi Schaefer made a dry wine two decades ago. Fresh green apples. Green apple skin. Sweet lemon. Almost savory. Deep. Juicy. Aged Riesling nose. Rocky mineral finish. Bought from Fass Selections. — 6 years ago

Gray Newman

9.1

Citrus pith and honey and lemon. Top notch. — 7 years ago

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.5

Stunning wine. Honeyed. But also slatey and wonderfully complex and nuanced. It screams of place. Schafer is amazing. Shows the richness of 07 with nice balancing acidity. Long, lean, juicy and amazingly complex. So pure. Haven't had Schaefer in a minute. — 7 years ago

Sara Miettunen

9.5

Ihana hapokas ja voimakas riesling — 8 years ago

Anthony Filiberti

Winemaker Knez Winery & Anthill Farms

9.0

Fully mature and still fresh — 8 years ago

Kati babinec

8.9

Tasty, smooth fruit with big chocolate notes! — 8 years ago

Jean-Pierre Meesters

9.5

This is really good. Verry young but already top. — 9 years ago

Jeremy Shanker

Sommelier at RN74

9.5

Another creature: a slightly oxidative St. Laurent rose that could be confused for aged Tempier or Lopez. Easily the best 2014 wine at the VDP Wienborse fair, and also one of the most interesting rose wines I have ever encountered. — 9 years ago

Ryan Mullins

10

Lawd, if you listen...help! Tasted again a week later....this wine is insane. Crazy wide bandwidth of flavor. Tart citrus to super ripe stone fruit. Sunshine in a glass. Like Riesling on acid with sunglasses on! — 10 years ago

Steve Anderson

9.0

Still drinking well. I'm familiar with the later history of Audelssa, but did not know about the Arrowood connection from 2000-2002. Interesting that this has "produced and bottled by Arrowood Vineyards & Winery" on the back and a Schaefer cork. — 10 years ago

Christopher Losa

Owner/Wine Director Bar Bambino

9.0

reviewing Schaffer’s wines is a task of choosing superlatives even when the wine is a low end of his spectrum. — 6 years ago

Peter van den Besselaar

9.0

Vintage 2011 - very nice developed smell with spring flowers and vanilla, vibrant! - at Bistro 253 at Remagen (ARP museum) — 7 years ago

Gabriella Boros

9.8

What an amazing wine. 2008 vintage which I bought at the Schaefer wine sale two years ago. First bottle was corked and trrribly moldy. Second bottle had a smooth and rich flavor straight from the first sip. Incredible body. Stank s are so mellow and round. An intense and special wine. Good fir Amy meal would be lovely with heavy meats. — 7 years ago

Marc On

Writer Originalverkorkt, Lobenbergs Gute Weine

9.2

First you get the typical Schaefer-Froehlich reduction on the nose but with some time it blows off. A lot of mineral notes, wet stone, sourcrout, fresh sliced white peach, elegant fruit. On the palate the acidity kicks in. Needs another two years to fully come together. Great QPR. — 8 years ago

Alexander Motola

9.1

Nice. At the same price not as nice as the Willi Schaefer from a few nights ago but more (nearly bone) dry. This was with spicy Asian food. Great nose. — 8 years ago

Veronica Castro

8.9

Lovely, spicy, and floral. Tastes like pineapple and lime and Dry, Dry, Dry! — 8 years ago

Vinny Eng

9.2

Perfect for fog, lamb dumplings & cumin. — 9 years ago

Peter van den Besselaar

8.9

Forster Pechstein 2006 Gr Gewachs Riesling, quite intruiging smell of apricot and wool, hay and butter. Crisp taste, very nice. — 9 years ago

Teemu Leminen

9.1

Alan korvata skumpan tällä. Sairaan hyvää! — 10 years ago

Petra Thieriot

Owner/Importer Dee Vine Wines

10

Auction! Just goes to show not all #Riesling 2003s suck! Schaefer BA is another testament to the most underrated "great" vintage-HA! #31DaysGermanRiesling #SOR @SummerRiesling — 11 years ago

with Dade

Christy Fitzgerald

9.2

Blueberry and nectarine Pitts on the nose with underlying earth notes. Upon first sip.... packs a surprising punch. Full bodied without being overbearing or harsh, coats the tongue, smooth and long lasting on the finish. Nicely balanced with acidity and underlying French oak. Just shy of a tawny but still a wine. Defiantly worth checking out! Neal Schaefer you need to try this one! I think you would be pleasantly surprised! — 7 years ago

John Kline

8.9

Crisp angular not that expressive. May need time — 7 years ago

Hugh O'Riordan

9.7

A delicious well balanced wine. A real bargain. Silky smith from beginning to end. Reminds me of Schaefer Hillside Select. — 8 years ago

Jason Adams

9.7

Damn!! I could drink this everyday — 8 years ago

Dan Horowitz

9.0

2012 has a nice silky body, notes of pepper cherry — 8 years ago

Katie Spigner

9.0

Grauburgunder. So hot right now. — 8 years ago

Zachery Groseclose

Old World Specialist B-21 Wines

9.5

Laser sharp 2013 — 9 years ago

Jörgen Lindström Carlvik

Owner, Brix Wine Consultants

9.7

VDP auction bottling. Hard to describe this one as its weightless and in complete balance. There's no hard edges anywhere, but still one of the most hardcore wines that I've ever tasted. The acid level tips the scales and its tart citrusy profile does include some tropical fruits but this this wine is all about its acid drive and nervous minerality. Unique. — 9 years ago

Kat Thomas

Sommelier Rose.Rabbit.Lie

10

We call this work-related studies — 10 years ago

with Jeffrey

Nicholas Livingston

9.7

What else belongs with salty apricot glazed ham? Thank heavens! — 10 years ago