Michael Squilla

9.6

One of my favorite scotches — 10 years ago

Diane Kessler

9.0

Just a fantastic Pinot that drinks way above its price point and I enjoyed it more than many other Pinots that cost more. Good time to be drinking this one. — 10 years ago

Mike Mayer

9.1

We are trying to figure this one out. Very subtle nose with an appealing bouquet. Silky cherries and red fruit on the pallet. Nice finish but very different (in a good way) than most pinots we drink. — 10 years ago

Gretchen Rogers

8.9

Good the first day. Better the next. Decanting will smooth this one out into the SLH you know and love. Luscious Pino. — 11 years ago

Erica Golden

9.0

This might make you say "America!" in an exclamatory way, like we won wine making. You should get involved with this one. — 11 years ago

Marybeth Cashman

8.9

Delicious Pinot. One of our favorite go-to reds. — 11 years ago

Michelle Hagen

9.3

A fantasy Pinot that lingers in your mouth far after it is gone. I really enjoyed this one! — 13 years ago

Davin Holen

9.2

Its the right amount of earthiness , rich bouquet, wonderful finish. Some wines finish with that sweet alcohol taste, not this one, earthy all the way through. 2012 vintage. — 10 years ago

Michele Strobeck

10

Wow - one of the most expensive bottles of wine I've ever tried. — 10 years ago

Pga

9.7

Joe Davis makes one of the finest Cali pilots. — 10 years ago

Cheryl Green

9.3

One of the nicest Pinots I've had recently. Berries at the front with a touch of spice at the finish. Very smooth and very easy to drink. Will definitely buy again. — 10 years ago

with Marc

Leonel Edwards

9.0

Excellent trying to get balance between $ and Tate and this one hits the spot — 11 years ago

Wes Galliher

9.4

One of the best chardonnay's I've ever had. Not too buttery, not dry, very good crisp white to drink on a warm evening. — 12 years ago

Konrad Michels

9.0

Not bad at all for a Pinot Noir. Not a type of wine I'd pick off a shelf anywhere, but if you have to drink Pinot, this probably is a good one. — 13 years ago

Troy Givens

9.3

This was one of the better Santa Lucia PNOs I've had. It's not one of those big fruit bombs. There's some minerality and a berry mid palette. — 10 years ago

Jim McCusker

9.3

From Pisoni's (excellent) second label Lucia, this was part of a three bottle horizontal consisting of the 2011 Santa Lucia Highlands, Garys' Vineyard, and Soberanes Vineyard offerings. The Garys' was definitely drinking the best, but I suspect this one will ultimately surpass it. Right now it's a bit too closed and probably should have been decanted. All three wines were terrific, though (not at the level of the Pisoni Estate, but still excellent wines). — 10 years ago

with Vanessa

Mark Kulpins

9.0

Day 1: Very pure bright strawberry and cherry. Super fresh and weightless.
Day 2: Damp earth, smoke, and spice....same weightlessness.
Two wines for the price of one. — 11 years ago

James Lee

9.2

The force is strong with this one — 11 years ago

Ellen Cohen

9.4

Jeff liked this one, better than cake reads — 11 years ago

Eric Hwang

9.9

Hands down, one of my favorite "accessible" Pinots. — 12 years ago