Unreal

Luyton Michéle

Hermitage White Blend 2018

Lyle Fass
9.5

Glorious nose of wild mint, wax, tree bark, pine resin, pine needles, some grilled nuts and just wonderfully pure. Superb richness but also fresh and pure aromas. 9.6 nose. So complex and nuanced. Palate is so elegant, so rich and has tremendous mineral freshness. Barely any fruit and such engaging and aggressive mineral and hay flavors. Amazing length and depth. Wow that length. Unreal texture and mid one can get lost in and that unique hermitage minerality. Superb. Needs air — 5 years ago

Severn, Michael and 6 others liked this

Domaine François Buffet

Taillepieds Volnay 1er Cru 2018

Lyle Fass
9.5

What a wine. This is a super star. Gorgeous cherry, raspberry cake, black cherry, just terrific spice but it’s also brooding and holding back. What a palate. Amazing texture and finesse. But huge tannins but really high quality. Lovely ripeness and perfect freshness. The nobility of the site is apparent in this wine’s elegant tannins and substantial structure. Unreal tiny berry fruit intensity. Has years to go but man this is a dynamite young Taillpieds. — 7 years ago

Aravind, Severn and 3 others liked this

Martin Müllen

Trarbacher Huhnerberg Spätlese Trocken Mosel Riesling 2018

Lyle Fass
9.5

Classic Hühnerberg with slate, spice, gorgeous spice, citrus up the wazoo. Tangerine, tangelo, kumquat, swimming pool, urinal cake, hint of rubber, lavender, flowers so so sick and so so complex. Fruit cocktail. But also a hint of savory. Palate is elegant, concentrated, sleek, mineral, straight as an arrow with unreal complexity, finish seems peppery, juicy, mineral explosion and citrus pithy explosion as well and ripeness that hints at sweetness but is still bone dry. Watermelon fruit. Finished salty, mineral and apricot pith. So so complex. So so long. Stunning. As usual. — 7 years ago

John, Matthew and 11 others liked this
Lyle Fass

Lyle Fass Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Matthew Cohen the note is here.

Weingut Josef Walter

Centgrafenberg Frühburgunder "J" Trocken 2013

Lyle Fass
9.6

Wow. Deeply fruited nose. So complex. Deep. What a stunner. Spice, mineral and violets for days. Amazing spice. Dark cherry fruit. Even some cassis. So vivid and pure. Wow. Wet leaves. Black tea. Dry leaves. Xmas spice. So layered and amazingly complex. A real wow nose. As soon as it’s popped. Palate is amazing. Sweet, complex and velvety with awesome balance and acidity. Amazing tiny berry fruit intensity and such stunning purity and texture. Best young Walter Frühburgunder I’ve ever had. Takes over your palate with a texture that is unreal. Stunning. Blown away. — 8 years ago

Severn, Matthew and 1 other liked this

Weingut Battenfeld-Spanier

Hohen-Sülzen Riesling 2015

Lyle Fass
9.4

Frigging unreal. What a nose. Just superb. Wide wide open aromas. Tangelo, lavender, honey, mineral, limestone and more. Even some sponti. Palate tastes like a baby GG. Incredible depth and richness yet so lithe. So clean and serious sap. Amazing power and concentration. Incredible and such a baby now. — 9 years ago

Tom, Riddley and 4 others liked this

Château d'Esclans

Garrus Côtes de Provence Rosé Blend

A great wine typically has a great length. Lagavulin scotch whiskey is one of those whiskey that has the greatest length (goes on for about 5 minutes). This rose has such a great length, it is unreal. — 11 years ago

Marchesi di Barolo

Gia Opera Pia Barolo Nebbiolo 1958

Unreal. Still lively and fresh! One of the best wines I've ever tasted. — 11 years ago

Château d'Yquem

Sauternes Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend 1921

#unreal : volatile, caramel, confiture de figue, crème brûlée cc @AGerbelle — 13 years ago

Drew liked this

Eric Pfifferling (Domaine de l'Anglore)

L'Anglore Tavel Rosé Blend 2010

CS
9.9

Righteous. This is what I wish most rosé would taste like. OR at least aspire to taste like. Unreal. Phenomenal. Electric. — 14 years ago

Domaine François Buffet

Pommard Pinot Noir 2019

Lyle Fass
9.4

Big, brawny, stoney and wonderfully aromatic nose. So Pommard. Mid to late season cherries. Fresh wood shavings. Stony minerality. So deep. Love that mix of 60% intense Pommard minerality and 40% gorgeous clear cherry fruit. Palate is divine. Gorgeous sweet fruit and glorious purity. Deep and wonderful. This is stuffed. Balanced and pure. Brawny yet elegant. Unreal length. The sun really shined on Pommard in 2019. Stunningly candied after 15 minutes on the nose. Confectionery. Just a stunning village wine. What a value! So fresh, so much energy and just stacked. But so elegant. This is one of the best value Village Pommards I’ve ever had. — 5 years ago

PS, Keith and 8 others liked this

Pierre Brisset

Les Noirots Chambolle - Musigny Premier Cru Pinot Noir 2018

Lyle Fass
9.6

What a nose. Unreal. Huge black and red cherries. Mineral. Loam. Blueberry, raspberry. Amazingly detailed fruit. So so saturated. Spice, so floral. Just a depth one can’t believe. Wow those inner mouth aromas. Massively concentrated, inky, dark and brooding, huge tannins, amazingly dense fruits, big tannins and and big acid, but amazingly vivid fruit despite all the bigness of the structure. Blackberry sap and extract are off the charts. This needs 5-7 years. Epic wine. — 7 years ago

Severn, Rob and 16 others liked this

Domaine Grosbot-Barbara

S.A.S Prince Charles-Henri de Lobkowicz St. Pourçain Chardonnay Blend 2015

Lyle Fass
9.4

What a wine and age has really improved this from super great to profound. Nose is gorgeous. Hint of butter, ripe pair, apple skins, lime blossom and intriguing and deep minerality. Palate is rich and ripe but laser focused with amazing texture that is like icing. It’s so fresh. The Tressallier really is an important factor in this wine as it makes it unique texturally and gives it unreal freshness. It’s so precise and refined with terrific juiciness and lovely taut structure and incredible length. The fruit is lime and apple skins all the way. The purity is incredible as is the length. Complex mid palate and even more complex finish with structure to burn and incredible inner mouth aromas. What a wine. — 7 years ago

La Rioja Alta

Gran Reserva 904 Rioja Tempranillo Graciano 2007

La Rioja Alta wines are world class and put Tempranillo in a class all its own. Bellota and Gran Reserva make for an unreal dining experience during the holidays in San Francisco. — 9 years ago

Salon

'S' Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil Brut Chardonnay 2002

Unreal, the most tiny bubbles — 10 years ago

Barnett Vineyards

Rattlesnake Spring Mountain District Cabernet Sauvignon 1998

Unreal on the tongue... — 11 years ago

Lindsay KaufmannMichael McConnell
with Lindsay and Michael
Lindsay and Michael liked this
Barnett Vineyards

Barnett Vineyards Influencer Badge

thank you for sharing!
Michael McConnell

Michael McConnell

Just exceptional
9.5

Château Lynch-Bages

Grand Cru Classé Pauillac Cabernet Sauvignon Blend 1990

Unreal. Everything Bourdeaux ever wanted to be. — 12 years ago

Santosh, Anthony and 1 other liked this
Greg Gregory

Greg Gregory Influencer Badge

Vintage?
Greg Gregory

Greg Gregory Influencer Badge

Yep. Truly a great wine. Had the 89 recently. I think I even like it a touch better. A bit more structure.

Pétrus

Pomerol Red Bordeaux Blend 2009

Alexis Davis Iaconis
9.3

As unreal as you would expect! The most impressive wine I've had in a while! — 14 years ago

Weingut Hermann Ludes

Thörnicher Ritsch Alte Reben Riesling Auslese 2015

Lyle Fass
9.6

The one and only! Just a genius wine. Nose is super herbal off the bat. A hint of creaminess. Really complex and just stunningly clean and vivid. I love Auslese. Wow what a palate. Engaging and intense. But filigreed and super light and elegant. Sappy and pure. Electric acids and wonderful sappy fruit and just unreal minerality. Finishes dry with a hint of foie gras which is classic Mosel Auslese character. Just a superb wine. Finishes salty, slatey and with lots of lime rock candy. Superb! — 5 years ago

barak heller, Vino and 14 others liked this

Domaine François Buffet

Carelles sous la Chapelle Volnay 1er Cru Pinot Noir 2018

Lyle Fass
9.6

Delectable ate my note but in a new weird way. Anyway, this is gorgeous. Cherry flower, sour cherries, so floral, so pretty. Such a Volnay nose. Classic nose. Palate is just stunning. Wow. Incredibly concentrated and so pure with a black cherry, late season red cherry fruit soak that is unreal. Clean, mineral and so so juicy. Balanced and so elegant with ripe and elegant tannins. Super high quality tannins and great freshness. Long, lingering black cherry on the finish. Hit of opulence just stays in your mouth. Just terrific fruit. It’s dense and elegant with just crazy energy and delineation. This is wow wine. — 7 years ago

Aravind, Severn and 3 others liked this

K.H. Schneider

Domberg Riesling 2016

Lyle Fass
9.4

Superb nose. Lemony infused minerals. Celeriac. Like Dr. Brown’s style. Jumps out at you. Deep white cherries. Amazing depth. Superbly confectionary. Wow. Such a nuanced, beautiful and delicate nose. Pithy apricot and peach emerge as well. Palate is so intense and mineral, crunchy almost. Palate is lean and mean with wonderful freshness, lift and acidity. It’s so complete and so deep. Incredible energy and balance. Finish of lemons and minerals and pithy fruits is so persistent. The attack on this is unreal. Just clamps down on the palate. Concentrated and structured this will last 10-15 years easy. Brilliant wine. — 7 years ago

Winzerhof Thörle

Probstey Riesling 2016

Lyle Fass
9.4

So good. Nose has a sense of richness from the warmer Probstey site, minerals and some peach and pineapple. Palate is unreal. Thörle killed 16. Huge acidity and freshness and a wealth of mineral tinged citrus and tropical fruits. Sick confectionary aromas after a while. What balance, poise and length. Open for business. Complex and structured and will age but lovely today. Very very impressive. — 8 years ago

Keith, Severn and 8 others liked this

Silver Oak

Alexander Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 1999

Thanksgiving treat... UNREAL — 9 years ago

Matt liked this

Domaine Jean-Louis Chave

Hermitage Syrah 1990

Andrew Tow
10

Words don't do it justice. This is my single favorite wine. Unreal in every way — 10 years ago

Roger liked this

Philip Togni Vineyard

Spring Mountain Cabernet Sauvignon 2011

Elegance in a bottle.. Near perfect mountain fruit from spring mountain with soft raspberry, minerality, and a touch of leather.. Smells unreal and tastes the same.. Rich but elegant and refined - like draping yourself in velvet. Phenomenal. — 12 years ago

Lundmark liked this

Maybach Family Vineyards

Materium Cabernet Sauvignon 2006

Paired with a great filet and al fresco. Unreal! — 12 years ago

Chris liked this

Bodegas Garcia Nino

Vino de la Tierra de Castilla y León Tempranillo 2005

Unreal... This cats total production is 12 barrels . A Castilla y Leon appelation not Ribera Del Duero . Non issue it's totally delicious . Dark purple. Sweet tannins and a never ending train of dark ripe berry fruit, — 13 years ago