Mark Freund

9.4

Showing terrific now. Better than last bottle opened 2 years ago. Honeyed richness, good length. Shows class joy would expect from the house. — 10 years ago

with Erin and Ned

Shaun McKinsey

9.4

New Year's Eve starting bottle. Fantastic opener! — 10 years ago

Judy Morris

10

Bought this for my daughters birthday dinner and it's fantastic! — 11 years ago

Dave Schneider

9.4

Fantastic wine. Lots of tanin and acidity to last a long longueville time. Tasted from a 375. — 11 years ago

John Wenzell

10

Gran Reserva for brother's 28th. Then, dinner and clubs! This wine is fantastic. — 12 years ago

with Phil

Rod Waterton

9.2

Fantastic....some black pepper yummmmm — 12 years ago

Drew Dodson

9.5

Birth year and still fantastic! — 10 years ago

Jim Davidson

10

Such a great wine from a fantastic vineyard. Smooth, hint of pepper, and full. Delicious. — 10 years ago

Mike Mayer

9.3

Lots of oak, dark fruit, smoke and earthiness on the nose. Very much a full-bodied 21st century Napa Cabernet. Fruit forward with silky tannins and a long luscious finish. A fantastic pairing with my NY Strip and Lisa's veal. — 10 years ago

with Lisa

Taft Morgan

9.0

Lovely noted of sweet strawberry jam and white pepper. The palate is a fantastic smoky beef jerky with floral perfume notes at the end — 11 years ago

with Ginette

Paul Fletcher

9.7

Just fantastic, with a finish that lasts a week. Still some soft tannins, and certainly not past it. — 11 years ago

Magno González

9.2

'09 shed most of its baby fat and is at a good place right now. Pure Joy! — 12 years ago

Amy Thornburg

9.7

Fantastic! Great violets on the nose, wonderful balance — 13 years ago

Sommsergio

9.3

Fantastic Sommelier Vintage! Drinking perfectly! Smooth tannins. Gorgeous and seductive! Another great wine day at Amangiri — 10 years ago

Mr.Pink

9.5

A lot of oak with berry berries and very dark color. A joy to drink. — 10 years ago

Andreas Holmberg

9.2

Fantastic! — 10 years ago

Pierpaolo Petrassi MW

Master of Wine; Head of Beer, Wine & Spirits Waitrose

9.5

Not the greatest of Bordeaux vintages (I remember a lot of rain!) but the great Chateaux made less and made it well. 21 years on, this wine has all the hallmarks of the greatest Clarets. Incredible concentration despite a moderate 12.5% alc. and incredible youth & fresh activist too. A rare joy. — 11 years ago

Darren Guillaume

9.4

Fantastic 2005 — 11 years ago

P S

9.3

Simply fantastic. — 12 years ago

Jess Rauchenstein

9.7

Fantastic!!!!!!! — 13 years ago

with Danny