Cédric Ménier

9.4

Sacré glouglou, la bouteille semble toujours trop petite — 8 years ago

Marguerite Realmuto

9.5

Finally opened a bottle from Chateau Neuf de Pape--
fabulous trip on the Rhone. — 8 years ago

Benjamin Keator

9.6

One of my go-to SB's for the summer. Love the big tropical fruits. Russell is a stud in pretty much everything he touches. Down to my last couple of bottles of the '13 but it is still killing it — 9 years ago

Westin Lawrence

9.0

Balanced and Smooth. Good texture — 10 years ago

Jeremy Rose

10

Russell From is a God. Hermanstorywines.com — 11 years ago

Tyler McNulty

9.5

Another perfect bottle — 11 years ago

with Matthew

Rishab Shanker

9.0

Nice full bodied wine — 11 years ago

Kevin DeBernardi

9.3

Bready, yeasty goodness. — 11 years ago

Karl Nichols

9.1

This was a surprisingly good rose from NY. — 11 years ago

Luis Ortiz

9.0

A proud Malbec. Mix of flavor with personality. Definitely worth another bottle. Old cheese a good friend. Steak even better — 12 years ago

Gordon Erickson

9.9

Had with Matt Luik, osseau irati cheese — 8 years ago

Brian S

8.9

Violets, cranberry and red cherry. — 8 years ago

Emily Anderson

9.0

Very nice Sancerre! Light but flavorful; dry and minerally. Bought it for Maisie’s lunchtime party. — 9 years ago

Raul Puga

9.6

Damn if Russell didn't do it again. Exquisite SB. Just plain YUMMY!! — 10 years ago

Céline Kiermeier

9.5

Smashing wine. Comparable to aged Chenins like those from Joly but with a gritty, gripping quality that can only be a sign of the vines' age. The 2005 consumed tonight had another 20 years of elegance. Unfortunate that this was our only bottle! — 11 years ago

with Shiraz

I Sax

8.9

Very nice for $16 — 11 years ago

Neil Summerour

9.0

Given my predisposition for temperanillos and malbecs, I was surprised how much I liked this. Light and somewhat sweet. — 11 years ago

Jusden Aumand

9.2

Working to the strengths of the vintage. — 11 years ago

Tannin Wine Bar & Kitchen KC

9.4

Dark & tart. Beets & blackberries. Full & rich Gamay. — 11 years ago

Matt Chaffin

8.9

I need help with this one too. — 14 years ago

RustyR

9.0

Chilled. White pepper earth raspberry. Slightly acidic but great for grilled food — 8 years ago

Jim McCusker

9.2

Another winner from Russell From at Herman Story. Great notes of dark chocolate, blackberry, and kirsch on the nose. Beautifully integrated palate with sweet, evolved tannins enveloped in fruit and glycerine, followed by a nice (albeit slightly hot) finish. Terrific. — 8 years ago

with Vanessa

Rick Walkup

9.2

Love this wine! Fruity no spice yet a bit rustic — 10 years ago

James Hockenberry

8.9

Very smooth. Not too spicy. — 10 years ago

Rebecca Combs

9.0

Tart red fruit aromas of cherry and underripe blackberry. A bit of leather on the nose. Medium tannin and medium body. On the palate, green bell pepper, tobacco, and black cherry — 11 years ago

Leslie Stone

9.5

Great wine! — 11 years ago

Josh Mazanowski

10

This is what it sounds like when doves cry — 11 years ago

Robert Branden Shine

9.2

20 percent chard, this wine is bigger than a New Zealand Sav Blanc. No oak, grapefruit, lime, jalapeño oddly enough and bell pepper. — 11 years ago

Michael Shearin

9.1

2008 vintage — 11 years ago

Steve Messinger

9.8

Great aromatics — 13 years ago