Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.1

Love this wine. Best value. Mulberry, spice, cinnamon, red fruits, sour cherry, rustic yet complex. Complex and silky with lovely tart cherry fruit and terrific freshness. Very linear and lovely mineral finish. Vibrant velvety tannins and as it opens up the depth is remarkable for such a value wine. Nice deep plummy mid. — 7 years ago

Antonio Galloni

Founder, Vinous

9.4

Exotic, deep bouquet of mulling spices, orange peel, sweet pipe tobacco and rose petal. Beautifully layered on the palate, with remarkable persistence and balance. Superb! 1947 Pontet Canet (recorked in 1986). — 8 years ago

Stewart Alsop

9.5

A splurge. This bistro has a remarkable wine cellar, which I'd like to adopt as my own! But just one bottle, and this was an excellent choice by Valerie. It took the whole meal to establish its personality, which is bold and complicated. — 9 years ago

with Valerie

Richard Portes

9.0

17.5. 2008. Remarkable transformation. First day ok, but not special. After a few days under argon, it blossomed. Rich and long. Try decanting. — 9 years ago

Greg Gregory

9.4

A remarkable wine, a bit like many ‘45’s in its power and concentration. And while those who are after some more of the La Chapelle structure may be disappointed (and I have sympathy with aspects of the assessment), this is such an full expression of fruit and terroir, that I can really only cheer. Plums, orange zest, pepper and currants on the enticing nose. The palate is awash in luscious, sweet fruit, soy tinged, with melting tannins, round and soft, pure velvet past the mid palate, and it finishes with gusto, batons twirling, with layered exuberance and appealing length. — 10 years ago

Greg Gregory

9.9

Byob. Wow is all I can say. If anything borders on perfection this wine is it. Truly a remarkable effort and kudos to Ann for such an amazing legacy of wines. Trust me, find the wine and buy it. — 10 years ago

David Hemmerling

9.4

Friend brought this 32 year old wine we have celebrated with them for many years. Decanted and drank with t day dinner. Remarkable longevity with good structure and color. Impressive. — 10 years ago

Michael Havens

9.1

Lively, more depth than last vintage, delicious. Remarkable value. — 11 years ago

with Paul

Marc O'Connor

9.9

Remarkable — 12 years ago

Howard Roselinsky

10

44 and still going strong. Remarkable eucalyptus nose. 2nd notes prominent with fruit hints in the background. — 13 years ago

Ryan Mullins

9.7

In such a fantastic spot with decades ahead. Taunt and wide. A remarkable wine — 8 years ago

Richard Sohn

9.3

Remarkable youth with freshness and ruby color. Plenty of fine tannins. Great balance. — 8 years ago

Trevor Maskell

9.6

1998. Great bottle. Still fresh. Sublime texture and flavour. Still has remarkable acid. Brûlée and zest flavoured. Superb length. — 9 years ago

Cary Kochman

9.0

Very nice but not as remarkable as its price. Likely needs even more time to mature into something better — 9 years ago

Sebastian Koncurat

9.3

Chocolate - tart black cherry cake flavors with an intoxicating - beautiful dark spicy aromas. This a multidimensional Dry-Creek Zinfandel, not super jammy, not super okay. .balance is remarkable — 9 years ago

Joe Roth

9.4

Remarkable. Smooth. — 10 years ago

with Michael

Eric Guido

9.3

This is already quite enjoyable, with a bouquet showing intense dark fruits, licorice, cedar and sweet spice. On the palate it displayed silky textures with vibrancy and remarkable freshness for the vintage. Tart blackberry, mushroom and tobacco lasted long into the finish, along with a tug of moderate tannin. — 10 years ago

Carl Fischer

9.0

Was worried after initial taste (nose of olives, bitter/sour cherries on the palate, acid, resolved tannins) but it was very good WITH food after about a two hour decant and even more remarkable considering its age. Very well-balanced and smooth. This is the second 20+ year old Seavey that I've had and I'm quite impressed with their ability to age. Though I prefer them with 5-10 years of age vs 20+. — 11 years ago

Nick Holmes

9.5

Day 2, remarkable — 11 years ago

with Julianne

Cathy Corison

Owner/Winemaker Corison Winery

9.4

Another lovely wine from this remarkable house. "Mystery wine" before our Brut Rosé tasting this week. Blind, I thought it was from the Loire. Rich, full, mineral. Electric acidity. — 12 years ago

Gerardo Suro

9.2

This is evolving nicely. Flowers, mint, bright cherries, minerals and silky tannins. Would’ve guessed red Burgundy if tasted blindly. Truly remarkable. — 8 years ago

Steven Gullo

9.2

Not a solid vintage but this is remarkable. Notes of menthol, eucalyptus, dried currants and a textural, lengthy finish. Could still see a few more years. — 8 years ago

Jack Suckling

10

This shows so much candied yet subtle grapefruit, orange and guava peel; yet the tertiary character is also deliciously prominent in the form of flint and straw box. The body is ridiculously intense given the reserved nose, uplifted by beautiful acidity and a seemingly everlasting finish. The flavors on the palate are even more impressive: passion fruit and chalk intermingle amid a very phenolic texture, playing off layers of dense white fruit. A white that's remarkable now but one that will age for still many years to come. — 9 years ago

Ryan Mullins

9.7

Consumed on one knee with head bowed! A remarkable bottle of pure and classic Rioja — 9 years ago

Robert Lim

9.0

Not to state the obvious, but this is really good. Agree it has an almost New World feel to it, remarkable. — 10 years ago

Taylor Stein

9.6

Such a babe. Remarkable wine and showing no signs of slowing down after 18 years. — 10 years ago

Richard Lewis

9.5

The main problem was that we opened it far too soon! A remarkable wine, beautifully light and deep at the same time. A lesson in not judging by alcohol % - you would never know it was 14.8. — 10 years ago

with Lynne

Randy Fuller

9.5

2011. The nose is full of red berries, with a dark flair. Raspberry, cherry, and red currant are met with Grahm’s signature savoriness of roasted meat, beef jerky and black olive tapenade. The sip reveals that the ‘11 Cigare is a festival of darkness. The savory aspects come forward in a rush. The forest floor, the olive, the spice - all are cloaked in a dark fruit setting. Black plums, currant and berries work hard to mesh with the wine's earthy character. The acidity is remarkable and the tannic structure is firm. — 11 years ago

Wilfred Wong

Chief Storyteller, Wine.com

9.1

Medium straw color; active stones in the aromas, keen and fine, some tart apples, excellent depth; medium bodied; dry, fine acidity, well balanced; bright apple flavors, maybe a note of chalk and sweet earth in the background; medium finish, lively aftertaste. This is a really fine effort and brings us back to the early years. The first vintage I tasted was the 1973, when it was just a baby and I really found it remarkable. (Best Served: 2014-2018) #chardonnay #napavalley — 11 years ago

Robert Craggs

9.7

Remarkable — 13 years ago