David Sweeney

9.3

Dope. Had it with a nice rib eye. 2010. Timed it just right. — 5 years ago

Ellen Clifford

9.1

I’d go so far as to call it great! Nice work Toad’s Hollow. — 6 years ago

Jeremy Hollingsworth

9.0

Deep purple with dark fruit, light oak and spice. Medium tannins with a nice long smooth finish. A great Napa Cabernet. Getting ready to enjoy it with some rib eye steaks — 7 years ago

with Dillon

Doug Scott

9.5

Guess this is young but very pure and clean fruit and acidity-tannin balance. Fresh herbs. Perfect with rib-eye steak. At Il Cortile Paso Robles. Actually have trouble not thinking this includes some Sangiovese, either coming from the winemaking style or just Tuscany in my head. — 8 years ago

Mike Allas

9.0

Good body lemon meringue flavor with white peach, with good acidity. — 8 years ago

Eric

9.6

Total beast. Did a quick double decant since it's 12 years old but should have let it open for a couple of hours. Eye watering nose of dirt, nutmeg, cinnamon, bramble, and camphor. Massive palate with plenty of fruit and tannin left. 45 second finish. What an awesome cab blend! — 9 years ago

Dean Quintal

9.3

Outstanding 2011. Full bodied pairs perfectly with a rib eye. Did not decant but opened up nicely by the last taste after about 1.5 hours. Highly recommend! — 5 years ago

Kristin the Wine Girl

9.2

Boldly bitey in the best of ways. Dark blueberry cappuccino. Coffee notes take the lead from lovely berries. Drink now. — 6 years ago

Michelle Connely

10

Decanted it. Didn’t particularly care for it by itself, or with my arugula salad with goat cheese, cashews, and yellow cherry tomatoes. It went well with the rib eye with blue cheese crumbles and the Brussels sprouts with bacon and yellow raisins. After the meal, the wine had opened up enough that it was excellent by itself. — 7 years ago

Jeremy Buss

9.1

Medium fruit on nose and medium (to slight below medium) tannins with a medium finish. Easy drinking wine that went well with pizza. — 8 years ago

Michael Greene

9.1

Cassis, tobacco, silky tannins. Needs time to open up so give it a good decant and then drink with food (a big rib eye, perhaps?) — 8 years ago

Hickoryburger

9.6

In a fascinating place right now. Cascades of depth, flavor and persistent notes of cherry, leather, occasional truffle notes and melting tannins. Paired with incomparable lamb chops and grass fed rib eye cap at LA's finest Argentinian restaurant Carlito Gardel — 9 years ago

Christopher Ciesiel

9.5

Eye: Ruby
Nose: Black cherry, currant
Palate: Nice tannins, baking spice, subtle oak
— 9 years ago

Norma Munoz

8.9

Was sold as Meomis Momma. Since I love Meomi, I tried it. Wasn’t disappointed. Drank incredibly well for such a young wine. Paired with a rib eye steak and great conversation. It’s a bit pricey though. — 6 years ago

Jessica Clark

9.3

Delicious wine, smooth, great with rib eye. — 7 years ago

The Meg

10

Whispering eye!! — 7 years ago

Ken Frank

9.8

The 96 is just off the chart good right now. Tasted through 6 vintages today working on a dinner for next week and this wine stunned. Near perfection and just entering the drinking window now. If you own this, get one out now! — 8 years ago

Euphrates Dahout

9.0

Surprisingly good for boxed wine. Balanced red sec, dried Italian cherries up front (though not too jammy) and notes of clove of the back end. — 8 years ago

Andrew Belzer

9.2

fresh cut grass with tropical nots of passion fruit, guava, and citrus — 8 years ago

Andrew Willingham

8.9

Pale, clear, Ruby on the eye with medium viscosity. Jammy baked cherries, some cured meat on the nose. Fizzy on your tongue. Sour cherries, strawberries, medium++ acid, and a long, mouth-drying finish. — 9 years ago