Eric Egan

9.3

If the 12 yo was poor, this is gold. Great to find it in a bar for £6 a shot! — 8 years ago

Gunja Gargeshwari

9.4

Best of the night - smooth with lots of character - better than Pappy 23 year old — 9 years ago

with Jason and Norman

Scott Samlan

10

Creamy smooth with incredible nice finish. One of the best I have ever had. For the price however I would take Michters 20 — 9 years ago

Rafael Landestoy

9.2

Pretty smooth. — 9 years ago

Sarah Wood

10

Really smooth. Not overly spicy but you can taste the flavors of caramel and vanilla. Rich aroma — 10 years ago

Eric Sobel

9.2

B3, delicious — 10 years ago

Jonas Johansson

9.0

This ale is great with FourRoses bourbon! — 10 years ago

John Berghoff

9.4

A Blanton's look a like at half the price. — 10 years ago

Matthew Finneran

9.4

Actually like the 10 more. Fruit forward. Christmas cake feeling. — 11 years ago

Ned Gray Creed

9.0

Nighty nightime nightcap. — 8 years ago

with Mark

John J

9.0

Toasty, caramel and viscous. Lovely! — 9 years ago

Donald Zeunert

9.6

Best bourbon next to Elmer T. — 9 years ago

Joe Mar

9.3

Honeyed vanilla, caramel and spice nose. Very smooth and mild heat. — 9 years ago

Garret Nagle

8.9

Vanilla, brown sugar, lemon curd, a little simple, more heat on the finish than I would like. — 9 years ago

David

9.0

Smooth, nice drink — 10 years ago

DAG

9.4

Colgin Pappy day 2 with Julian Van Winkle and @Paul Roberts — 10 years ago

Elyse Lichtenthal

8.9

I was introduced to my first Rye tonight...ever. Not sure what I should taste for ( other than smoky burning) but it was just the right amount of smoke, bite, and happiness for happy hour. I dig it. — 10 years ago

Ryan Mullins

9.6

Better than I remember — 11 years ago

Rachel Moore

8.9

Good but for the price and demand, no, — 12 years ago

Phillip Antley

9.0

Toffee and brown sugar, almost candied fruits. Mid-palette to the finish is a bit one dimensional, but a great go-to bourbon. — 8 years ago

Mike R

9.3

Just need some diversification on a Sunday

Really good — 9 years ago

Luke Ragland

9.5

Very hot on the nose. cinnamon and caramel. Cut with a few drops of water and richness comes through. Amazingly long finish. Top notch. — 9 years ago

Richard Sohn

8.9

Well-rounded. — 9 years ago

Kary Vega

9.3

Just got this. — 9 years ago

Sean Diaz

9.5

Mmmmmm. That's the stuff. — 10 years ago

Jonas Johansson

9.2

Good times in Nashville. — 10 years ago

Matt Sterr

9.0

Big and brawny with lots of oak. Tobacco and allspice are present as well. — 10 years ago

Jeffrey Long

8.9

Goes well with egg nog and sad sad Raider's interceptions. — 11 years ago

Peter Alexandrov

9.7

Great bourbon whiskey. Gift by Nikita in NY in Dec 2012 — 13 years ago