Laith A

9.3

Baby Brunello .. excellent wine! — a month ago

B

10

1998 Sassicaia. Latm dinner at Ner. I preferred this over the 1999 Valdicava Madonna out of 3L. This wine had great length, lots of fruit, and didn’t feel as lean as the Madonna. — 3 years ago

Chris LoRusso

8.9

Big into Rosso's lately. Enjoyed this wine.. Nice earthy w dark fruit, butwas missing the long finish that some of the better ones have. Valdicava '11 still a favorite! — 6 years ago

Gor

9.2

So young still. Bricking a little with garnet color. Rose garden, leather, plum, cherries, black currant, spice box, cedar on the nose. Still somewhat austere after 4 hours of air. Could be mistaken for a left bank. Tannin is powerful and this seems like it could keep aging for some time. Not as balanced as when I had it last time. — 2 months ago

James Parker Huston, CWE

Sommelier Charlie Palmer

9.5

In a great place. Called it 1990 Valdicava. Pretty happy with that call. — 6 years ago

Richard Young

Wine Specialist Christie's

9.0

Mandatory Riesling. Valdicava vertical behind — 9 years ago

Inseon Hwang

8.9

It’s fine/good. Don’t love it. Doesn’t really stand out. — 2 months ago

Gunja Gargeshwari

9.1

It followed a Poggio Antica Brunello from 2007 and showed beautifully. Was eclipsed by the Valdicava Brunello later in the night — 3 years ago

with Norman

Rob Freelen

9.4

Great Brunello, more restrained than Valdicava. Great nose, smooth and structured. #ehrlich #winegeek2q2014 — 8 years ago

with Marc and Eric