Scott Samlan

10

Creamy smooth with incredible nice finish. One of the best I have ever had. For the price however I would take Michters 20 — 8 years ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.0

SD 11/18/16 — 9 years ago

Mike Steinberg

8.9

An old favorite from Burrowing Owl Winery. Nice and rich though not as bold as some other vintages. — 9 years ago

Mike Ancuta

9.8

Supwr smooth, one of the best I have had — 10 years ago

Matthew Finneran

9.4

Actually like the 10 more. Fruit forward. Christmas cake feeling. — 11 years ago

Deborah Heath

9.6

Islay flight #2: Kilchoman Machir Bay. From Islay's newest distillery. Heady convergence of peat, flowers, fresh mown grass — 12 years ago

Jeroen de Jong

9.5

Surprised me, bold flavors, many layers, pepper, chili, vanilla. Long finish with complexity — 8 years ago

Tim Laffoon

9.5

Complex flavor, spicy yet smooth — 9 years ago

with Michelle

DAG

9.4

Colgin Pappy day 2 with Julian Van Winkle and @Paul Roberts — 10 years ago

Mike Stone

8.9

Yes, you can make a Manhattan with Irish.... — 10 years ago

Neil Shah

9.2

Wish I could wait long enough for this to age, but it's so nice. — 10 years ago

Rachel Moore

8.9

Good but for the price and demand, no, — 11 years ago

Eric Hiatt

9.6

Spicy and warming. Delightful — 12 years ago

Michael Chase

9.8

Deep purple in colour. Some sediment. Cedar, tobacco, black currant on the nose. Black fruit, tobacco to taste. Long finish. Opened up in the glass. Could handle one to two more years in the cellar. — 8 years ago

David

9.0

Smooth, nice drink — 9 years ago

Rob Mayes

9.2

Very nice. Tastes like watered down 18 — 9 years ago

Elyse Lichtenthal

8.9

I was introduced to my first Rye tonight...ever. Not sure what I should taste for ( other than smoky burning) but it was just the right amount of smoke, bite, and happiness for happy hour. I dig it. — 10 years ago

Dave Harris

9.3

Macallan 12. Great integration of caramel and peat. — 10 years ago

John Ingram

10

Truly special stuff — 11 years ago