Marc Bidder

9.0

Punching so far above its weight class it's absurd. Need to try more Barthod. Another superb Rosenthal selection — 10 years ago

Rebecca Kanter

9.6

Happy wine in my happy place with my happy person. Not sure if life actually gets better? best value in white burgundy - punches above its weight — 10 years ago

with Dan

Emily Yoo

9.3

Great bubbles, complex on the back end. A steal at €27, and head and shoulders above its peers. — 11 years ago

Wineshout 💀

8.9

Merlot with a dash of Syrah, this wine gives you red cherries and dusty blackberries with a sprinkling of pink peppercorns. Punches above its weight class.

Full review at wineshout.com

Wineshout.com — 11 years ago

James Leahy

9.1

2012 vintage. The old vines trick your pallet into thinking its chassagne until the minerality settles in and brings the classic Meursault backbone. Long finish. Drinks well above village level! — 11 years ago

with Liz

Ben Sacks

9.1

Full bodied and well-balanced. Delicious chard but priced well above what most are willing to pay for CA Chards. — 12 years ago

George Chen

9.4

Not ever sure why the 61 vintage sells at or even above Petrus price as I've never had it but rest of the old vintages are just lovely and relatively a bargain! This bottle had all the nuances and elegance of a fine lady at ease with oneself. Love it! — 10 years ago

Leah Amir

9.0

Drinking above its appellation — 10 years ago

Joel Tan

9.3

Darker red fruits, blackcurrant, tinge of sweetness, soft tannins that faded with air, denser and really punched above its weight — 10 years ago

Drew King

9.5

Had the 2012 (can only find the 2012 magnum on Wally's Wine and Spirits Website, and well worth it as it's above and beyond the '13) on our honeymoon in Kauai at the St Regis Kauai Grill. Wonderful wine that barely needs need to breathe and can be pretty much paired with anything. — 11 years ago

Tyler Durham

9.1

Lovely balance, opened up with a bit of aeration and punched well above its weight. — 11 years ago

Andrew Lubeck

9.0

Liger-Belair - elegance and class. Better as night wore on ~3 hrs in. Pure fruit and nice structure. drinks way above village level — 11 years ago

Christine Mortensen

9.8

Very tasty! As Lloyd put it... "It's a step above our wine in a box." :) — 13 years ago

E & K G

9.1

First #leroy ever! Punching well above it's regional appellation. @坐漁荘 — 10 years ago

Shay A

9.0

I'm fairly new to Girard wines, but really quite fond of this cab blend. I've tasted the '11 as well and this seems to be a step above. Really opens nicely after a bit of a decant...medium bodied but full of great flavor. — 10 years ago

Phil Bogard

9.3

Drinking way above its pay grade.... Again. I love 96 Bordeaux. Beautiful nose with plenty of fruit but telltale pepper. Long life. — 10 years ago

Judd Blair

9.5

As far as big houses go, always been a fan of the special cuvée. This is a cut above - lots and lots of biscuit and toast, but very well integrated, bit of dried apricot and a slight tinge of bitter oxidation rounding out this one - fantastic sparkler. — 11 years ago

Jeremy Giesbrecht

9.3

83 vintage was showing strong tannin still... Lovely wine, everything there but definitely in to secondary flavour characteristics. Even this far back Pontet-Canet was punching above it's 5th growth status. #mtlwinethrowdown — 11 years ago

Will Taylor

9.1

Great value claret with a bit of age, punching well above! — 12 years ago

terroirista-cy

9.6

First time tasting Lisini wines. This was straight forward great Brunello & above all w/ no vanilla..... Traditional style all the way, elegant with great fruit & balanced — 12 years ago