Scribe

Cabernet Sauvignon 2008

Rob Stutzman

9.2

Still a huge wine. Eat with it. — 9 years ago

Scribe

"VI. The Hunter" Carneros Pinot Noir

Daniel Wisner

9.0

Yum. New world Pinot. Great for a cab lover. Not as heavy as Meiomi. — 9 years ago

David and Mike liked this

Scribe

IV. Odd Angel Pinot Noir Rosé 2015

Wayne King

9.7

First time tasting this rose. It was delightful on a warm afternoon — 10 years ago

Scribe

Ode to Emil No. 11 Sylvaner

Doblas

9.0

Great with sushi! Clean and strong mineral flavors... Enjoy! — 11 years ago

Henschke

Mount Edelstone Vineyard Shiraz 2005

Bob McDonald

8.9

This is the 6th of an original 6 and from the first bottle the tasting notes have been consistent. This wine has a weird vegetal nose. I have described as H2S in previous notes. This off putting note does not come through on the palate which exhibits ripe fruits with raspberry to the fore. Finishing off with trademark silky tannins. As a coincidence of timing it's illustrious elder brother Hill of Grace - the 2012 vintage was just judged Wine of the Year by Australia's leading wine scribe James Halliday. Well done to Henschke. — 9 years ago

David, Aaron and 5 others liked this

David L

Good to know about the 12

Aaron Tan

Hard decant?

Bob McDonald

@Aaron Tan certainly had a good decant. I have had Edelstones from many vintages over the years and have always found them exemplary. For the 2005 over 6 examples I would say faulty winemaking for this vintage.