Randy Fillingim

9.5

As good a Pinot - 2009. - that I have had. Seamless. Tannins and fruits in near perfect harmony. Initial taste - amazing. AND it finishes just as good. — 4 years ago

Amy Yan

9.1

Hit the wine jackpot on a work trip! One of two leftovers from the table next to me! Excellent Pinot. Lots of fruit and doesn't taste like a classic Pinot. Smokey wine indeed! — 7 years ago

Michael O'Sullivan

9.2

Big, complex, cranberries, fine grained tannins- mineral — 8 years ago

Matt Sterr

9.1

Majority Cab Franc with Cab Sav and Carmenere. Luscious with tons of cherry 🍒 fruit and a nice expression of the terroir of the region. — 9 years ago

Luis Arguero (@winefromAtoZ)

9.1

Amazing wine! Such a smooth, perfectly balanced wine. Such an awesome value. Wish all wines were like this! — 9 years ago

Gary Moreno Jr.

10

Always my favorite — 10 years ago

Paul Mcnamara

9.8

Nice with Lamb — 13 years ago

Austin Blackwell

9.5

LOVE this stuff! Much better than the 2013. Has more body and richness. — 6 years ago

with Angelina

Pam Hoadley

9.8

Smooth and light but rich flavor (TalentConnect2018) — 7 years ago

Tobin Spratte

9.1

Tasted in 2015: First pour a bit hot, even caustic, but after allowing it to breathe, second pour is much more balanced and reveals aromas of tar, ash, black pepper, violets, raspberries, and a hint of cherry cola. More breathing still showed brown sugar and herbal aromas. — 8 years ago

Bobby Feldman

9.7

Aged very well! — 9 years ago

with Marycarl

Rebecca Fletcher

9.3

Floral, violet, earth, spice, red cherry. M+ acid, m front tannin, m body. M+ intensity. Tart cranberry, red cherry and raspberry. Long finish. — 10 years ago

Michelle Brandenburg

9.7

Floral aroma — 11 years ago

Peter Sidell

9.4

Kind to the palate — 6 years ago

George Chen

9.3

14 drinking near peak of mature brightness and silky tannins - really balanced front to back...I really love Melville! I think it’s the most underrated winery in the US likely! Really expressive and nice pure fruit! — 6 years ago

Jody Scharf

9.3

Syrah the hidden gem. Blackberry, earthy. Real nice. Glad I'm involved. — 8 years ago

Casey Stringer

9.6

I know it's over the top,but damn it taste good. — 9 years ago

Donna Liu

9.0

Light structure with excellent balance, dried cranberry depth balloons into a nuanced finish. — 9 years ago

Cathy Madison

8.9

At Nirvana for work function — 10 years ago

P Pelissero

9.8

One of my favorite Pinot's. Part of our wine club from Los Olivos, CA. MMMM... — 12 years ago