Robert Wolfe

9.3

This is finally old enough to have unwound and now it shows its true volume and depth. Drinkable now for scads of beautifully ripe fruit, but nowhere near maturity. — 10 years ago

Nathaniel DiMaggio

9.1

Very fresh! Great bubbles, beautiful, fresh apple and pear fruit. What a treat. — 10 years ago

with Todd, Mariah and 2 others

J Manncini

9.8

This is a favorite at the house. One of the best champagnes I have had by far. — 12 years ago

Paul Costigan

Founder Courtier Wines

9.5

1973: Beautiful bottle. Wines like this make everyone stop and take notice. The color was clear and light. Arresting nose full of plums and roasted beets. The depth of flavor and long finish was in contrast with the appearance. Really a fine experience, only second to the few times I had the 1952 Mont Real. — 10 years ago

with Barry

Nicholas Tolson

9.9

I can't see myself liking and enjoying a Chardonnay any more than this one. Butter. Recommended by Bryan Smith, wine director at Woodward Table. — 11 years ago

Steve Matthiasson

Owner/Winemaker Matthiasson Wines

9.7

2008. Gorgeous red fruit, seamless pebbly tannins, world class wine — 12 years ago

Philippe Broom

9.3

Amazing, moscatel heaven — 10 years ago

Olivier Schutte

9.7

Incredibly complex, changes through the evening, superb — 10 years ago

Patrick Berry

9.0

p good n cheap — 12 years ago

CS

Sales Amy Atwood Imports

9.0

The cork-whisperer. And his first saberism. Mag de Coquillette Brut a Chouilly. — 13 years ago