Anthony Iandoli

8.9

Ken this is a solid Zin for the price! And it's great with a Montecristo Habana no DOB pin required — 10 years ago

Dave Harris

9.5

Ardbeg Uigeadail Whisky. Nose is sweet, with fruit, peat, and vanilla extract. Smokiness comes out in taste, and pettiness becomes more prominent. Still very little peat for an Islay malt. Long lasting with great fruity finish. Outstanding.
Cigar is Montecristo Espada Toro. Beautiful draw. Flavor in the first third is campfire wood, chocolate, burnt coffee. Fantastic. 9.3 — 10 years ago

with Efrain

José Alejandro Pachano

9.0

Excelente Vino, muy fresco al paladar, debidamente acompañado con un habano Montecristo Edición Especial New York! Con Mr. Aguilar en el bunker del Sarna! — 11 years ago

Lewis Chester

9.2

2003 vintage. From Jay. Very nice. Much better than expected. Goes down all together way too easily when you're surrounded by snow! Deep ruby core washing out towards the edges. No bricking...yet. Nose is a preponderance of dark fruits together with blueberries and ripe cassis with slight under tones of cloves and a hint of graphite. This is a very fruity affair- takes me back to Christmas. The wine expresses on the palate as it does on the nose. Layers of rich fruit with traces of brown spice. There's a lovely sweetness here that makes the wine a pleasure to drink despite the relatively modest acidity. The tannins are soft and lush. The finish is good with a continued preponderance of fruit right to the very end although it is moderate in length. This is a very quaff able wine...could be at this all night with pleasure just sit me down in front of an open fire and hand me a Montecristo! 92+/100. Drink now to 2028. NB - no need to decant. This wine can happily be poured from bottle post opening and allowed to open in the glass. — 10 years ago

Blaine Brown

8.9

Nice fizzy lifting drink to get the party started with enough cement to keep you grounded. — 11 years ago

Carmen Walter

9.3

Der Wein leuchtet herrlich rubinrot. Er zeichnet sich aus durch ein kraftvolles und fruchtiges Bukett von reifen, dunklen Beeren. Finale Deutschland:Argentinien — 11 years ago

Eric Egan

9.3

If I could drink this every day for the rest of my life I'd be delighted! Textbook Margaux with blackberries, blackcurrents, Montecristo No. 1, hot leather, and hints of tarmacadam and a freshly seasoned humidor. Deep whale-blood hue with a hair-fine halo of quicksilver around the edge. Balanced but still with prickly tannins and evident acidity. Divine! — 10 years ago

Humberto

9.4

Shoe shine guy taking care of the your fine leather shoes, another guy smoking a good montecristo outside a coffee shop next to you. Sweet vanilla, tobacco leather minerals cocoa and flowers blending magnificently on you palate forcing you to remember that he came from that soil.... Sublime ....awesome, classic and rustic in the same breath ... Wow — 10 years ago

James Leahy

10

The brute in the lineup. Would be a perfect complement to Montecristo No. 4 for me. Exceptional. — 11 years ago