Frank Rotello

9.1

Very soft. Drank it too quickly. Nice tart cranberry fruit. Smooth tannins — 10 years ago

S Butterfield

Sommelier Flask Fine Wines

9.2

Totally Italian. Approachable yet pronounced tannins that smooth off with air. Lovely earth and fruit aromatics. Carmignano is my jam. — 10 years ago

Kirk Ellis

8.9

Nice Italian with Hungarian Beef Stew — 10 years ago

Anne Carman

8.9

Surprisingly smooth structure starts off, blending the grape varietals well to a smooth elegant finish. With spicy southern Italian fare this wine holds up strong. 2011 vintage. — 11 years ago

Jeff Vejr

9.1

Before James Suckling and The term "Super Tuscan" there was a producer making blends with French grapes for more than 300 years....this is a wine that will confound the haters, and hopefully reeducate them. — 11 years ago

Benjamin Farrer

9.8

Chambers Street Wines, ~$30 — 12 years ago

with Jennifer

Paul Heyrman

9.3

Cherry Sangiovese aroma. Drinking perfectly. — 10 years ago

Shanna Delph

9.0

Big ripe cherry deliciousness — 10 years ago

Norma

9.7

Grapefruit and honey, spicy and crisp — 10 years ago

Phil Kessling

9.1

2001, Madonna delle Grazie Il Marroneto Sangiovese. A Brunello with 14 years of aging, doesn't get much better. Still has primary black fruit but layers of secondary flavors. It continues to open up and get more complex through the evening. — 11 years ago

Dan Fredman

Chef Sommelier World of Pinot Noir

9.1

Delicious, cherry, pomegranate, touch of oak, medium finish. Great value for the money. — 11 years ago

Kathy Thile

9.8

Fabulous!!!!! — 12 years ago

James Hanus

9.6

Delish as — 12 years ago

Matt Dodd

9.0

Really good. — 10 years ago

Vinny Eng

9.4

Living for Love.
I'm living for Love.
I'm not gonna give up
Love is going to lift us up!
#trossen
#hitthespätlese
#papapreachesforriesling — 10 years ago

with Chris and Wolfgang

Mark N Ricca Jr

9.0

Really gorgeous 2001 vintage. All elements fully integrated. Cherry and red currant fruit, allspice, medium tannins, tobacco. Paired with grilled pork, Romano cheese, and parsely sausage. — 11 years ago

Kurt-Inge Eklund

9.4

The wine of the evening! — 11 years ago

Louy Theeuwen

9.4

Mouthwatering and smooth with a velvety finish. — 11 years ago

Mick McHale

9.1

Great find... Loved it — 12 years ago

mami sugihara

9.6

Chardonnay like Italian. — 12 years ago