Joe Carroll

Owner/Wine Director Spuyten Duyvil, Fette Sau, St. Anselm & Gotham Artisanal Provisions

9.3

In great shape. Tannins, fruit and acid all in balance — 9 years ago

Robert Lim

9.3

Decent fruit, pleasantly earthy with all those grandfatherly notes. Back vintage Gattinara so cozy right now. 1967 vintage, enjoyed at Maialino last week — 10 years ago

with Rich

Andrew Mecoli

9.3

Great earthy nose, powerful overall. — 10 years ago

Ezra Wicks

8.9

2008. Deep, deep, so much more than a sforzato. Had it open a week and it kept drinking. "The dream" indeed. — 11 years ago

Christian Gourdin

10

Killer wine — 11 years ago

Phil Kessling

10

2007, Anzivino, Gattinara Nebbiolo. Second bottle and is ageing well. Great with grilled ribeye. Black fruit, leather, forest floor; smooth and complex. — 12 years ago

Adri G. Piece

9.1

Papito chulo — 13 years ago

Matt Perlman

9.4

Cork pulled cleanly; still in excellent condition. Took my time enjoying the rose petal, soil and truffle aromas and the dried sour cherry, earth, mushroom, and briney flavors, nicely complemented by a beautiful mushroom risotto courtesy of @Steven Perlman. — 9 years ago

with Steven

Paul Lysek

Sommelier at Joe's Seafood, Prime Steak, & Stone Crab

9.5

Fucking bomb. — 10 years ago

Mike Petonic

9.6

I agree with Davis, this is pretty great. Still has structure and a fruit balance with the right amount of tannins. Go figure that we were at Acquerello when we had this. We have a more recent vintage if this that we're going to save for a decade or more. — 11 years ago

with Veronica

Magnus Mosén

8.9

Mellovinet! Bärig doft men en hint av risbastu. Mjukt och välbalanserat. Prisvärt! — 11 years ago

Gillian Robb

9.1

Delicious. Picked up another bottle to keep for a few years. Luxardo cherries, rain on hot asphalt, dried orange rind. Lovely. — 11 years ago

with Thomas, Ali and 1 other

A J

9.7

Really nice $30ish — 12 years ago

Michael Retter

9.0

Strong tannins and well structured. Pair with charred red meat and sunchokes - worked quite nicely. — 10 years ago

David D

9.2

Mellow but full bodied, very dry, black tea, raisins, ink, cranberry, nice mouth-drying tannins. From Shawn's. — 10 years ago

Raff

9.3

Soft ripe fruits and tobacco on the nose. Amber red in colour. Soft tanins, mild pear, and tobacco notes. Finishes on notes of smoke. My dining companion compared it to the wine he would drink for the rest of his life. Stellar representation of quality Italian wines — 10 years ago

Luca De Chirico Bacer

9.7

2004 vintage — 11 years ago

with Tommy

Alder Yarrow

Wine Blogger Vinography

9.0

Nutmeg, cinnamon, cedar, red currant. Very pretty. — 11 years ago

Erica Lasswell

9.8

Awesome for the $!! — 12 years ago

Austin Beeman

9.1

Dark dry taut chocalote cinnamon. Very nicely old school. $36 — 12 years ago