Brad Mate

9.0

This wine is kind of an anomaly. Light and somewhat lean but super super smooth and round on the palate. While fruit and tannin are shy, the silky mouth feel wins me over. — 10 years ago

Josh Rutherford

9.5

A perfect example of the excellent fruit that is grown in the Applegate Valley. Aged with incredible grace. — 10 years ago

John Kemper

9.4

An anomaly, the '12 Herman Story Pinot Noir 'Smash City' is one over-the-top Pinot that will stare down a spice-rubbed chargrilled steak without blinking. A 15.4% monster that throws gobs blueberry aromas and sweet fruit flavors. This 71 case effort by Russell P. From from the Murmur Vyd. in Santa Maria Valley will never be mistaken for a Burgundy. I'm so glad we flew to the Central Coast just to sample. — 11 years ago

Richard Steinberg

9.4

This is very rich and wel@ structured Deep blue fruit. Hedonistic. — 10 years ago

Daron Watson

8.9

cherry, peach & plum put, watermelon rind — 10 years ago

David Stein

9.3

This bottle was much better than the last one. (Must have been anomaly). Leave it some time to open. It's in the zone. — 11 years ago

Rajat Parr

Founder Sandhi Wines & Domaine de la Côte, Evening Lands Vineyards, Seven Springs & Maison l'Oree

10

denser more serious and structured wine with chiseled opulence, an anomaly in the best way — 12 years ago

Larry Gioia

10

Amazing Italian wine restaurant that's been open a month in Copenhagen. Wines on the shelf are the same price at the table - an anomaly for Denmark (or any country for that matter!) — 10 years ago

Perry Croft

9.6

Kind of an anomaly for Cobb wines in that reaches 14% abc, but one of the sexiest Ross Cobb made wines I've had. — 11 years ago

Scott Reiner

9.2

An anomaly. Drinking well. Classic. 13 pct. wonderful. But drinking well now. — 11 years ago