James Muntz

9.0

Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde here. Day 1 tight and maybe even a little muddled in the flavor department. Day 2 deep dark cherry flavor - enjoyable. — 11 years ago

Nick Popio

9.5

Beautifully crisp, one of the best Rieslings I've had. — 11 years ago

Jerry Hindes CS, CSW

9.4

3 ltr. $500. Sold 2. Great party. They loved that Charles Wagner hand signed the bottles. — 11 years ago

Rhett Butler

10

Bye bye! :( — 13 years ago

Erin Bailey

9.4

My first love when it comes to Finger Lakes Reds. Not a great vintage for Reds, but the shorter growing season for pinot snuck this one in under the radar. Lots of cherries and a hint of maybe olives? It has some lively acidity that makes it dance on your tongue. It's got the red strength without being overpowering. Beautiful with seafood. — 11 years ago

Marisa Reisman

9.2

I picked this wine, so clearly I like it. Fun Pinot because it is made by the Wagner family from Caymus, so a Pinot nurtured by a cab expert — 11 years ago

with Levon, Adriana and 2 others

Jason Wild

9.5

Exceptional year in upstate New York! Wagner only makes their Meritage blend from the best of the best years! A cooler climate red blend with great balance between darker fruit flavors, tannins and oak. — 12 years ago

R. Addison Wehrfritz

9.0

Wagner family wine recipe: well-extracted and concentrated fruit, robust oak profile, with a touch of RS. Not a sophisticated wine, but does it need to be?! This juice is smooth. — 11 years ago

Josh Orr

9.2

#wopn2015 — 11 years ago

with Branden and Mike

Jason Wild

9.6

Amazing vintage! This riesling has great balance. Minerality, lemon, lime, honeyed apricot, acid backbone. This is a riesling to age! — 12 years ago