Mike Ancuta

9.8

Supwr smooth, one of the best I have had — 10 years ago

Matthew Finneran

9.4

Actually like the 10 more. Fruit forward. Christmas cake feeling. — 11 years ago

Deborah Heath

9.6

Islay flight #2: Kilchoman Machir Bay. From Islay's newest distillery. Heady convergence of peat, flowers, fresh mown grass — 12 years ago

Ryan Frank

9.3

Sweet, spicy, and bottled at just the right age and proof. Spectacular offering from #Balvenie. — 11 years ago

Dave Harris

9.3

Macallan 12. Great integration of caramel and peat. — 11 years ago

John Ingram

10

Truly special stuff — 12 years ago

Mike Stone

8.9

Yes, you can make a Manhattan with Irish.... — 11 years ago

Neil Shah

9.2

Wish I could wait long enough for this to age, but it's so nice. — 11 years ago

Rachel Moore

8.9

Good but for the price and demand, no, — 12 years ago

Eric Hiatt

9.6

Spicy and warming. Delightful — 13 years ago