Domaine Philippe Tessier

La Porte Dorée Cour-Cheverny Romorantin 2011

9.0

Cases of mistaken identity. Thought I was buying a Sauvignon Blanc. Nope. Then, thought I was drinking a Chenin Blanc. Nope. In the end, a pretty profound wine, bit oxidative and with a whiff of apple cider. Good stuff. — 10 years ago

Peirson Meyer

Russian River Valley Pinot Noir 2012

Charlie Beatty

Buyer wineworksonline.com

9.8

Impressive Pinot Noir Peirson Meyer has had a Identity Crisis. In years past they operated with 2 different labels. The other being L'Angevin !! That label is now on the back label!!! — 11 years ago

Charlie and Brian liked this

Charlie Beatty

Now the profile has matured and shows Great Fruit Component and layers of complexity . I give this a CB 93-94 rating thanks to the one label!! Bravo! A MUST BUY!!

Grand Rêve Vintners / Force Majeure

Ciel du Cheval Vineyard Collaboration Series VI Cabernet Sauvignon Blend

Andrew Lampasone

Owner Wine Watch Selections

9.4

Southern Rhine blend Mourvèdre dominant 56, Syrah 38, 6% Grenache made by James mantone, syncline winemaker, fermented in concrete has a good amount of blackberry huckleberry fruit with notes of animal, Dark spices. This has a bit of estate fruit which is third leaf from the stolen fruit incident. Black licorice spice 1.5 tons stolen- around 50 cases. Dark spices and pretty floral notes very pretty this needs a rack of lamb still has that dusty mineral notes. Big and chewy with rich decadent fruit and bright acidity cleaning things up with pretty floral notes only 220 cases produced. Finish 45+ dusty mineral notes through the finish. Excellent+ — 12 years ago

Mistaken Identity

BC Gulf Islands VQA 2012

Yohanna

9.3

Great aromatics with lovely dry finish thats unexpected given the fruit and floral characteristics on the nose — 10 years ago

Marcel Lapierre

Morgon Gamay 2009

Benjamin Parniuk

9.3

Beaujolais has stolen my heart away from St. Joseph. This just adds to the list. — 10 years ago

Anthony, Travis and 2 others liked this

Gimenez Mendez

Identity Edición Limitada Merlot 2011

Michael Wangbickler CWE DipWSET

President Drink Local Wine Inc, Educator Discover Wine & Spirits Academy

9.1

Best merlot I've had in a while. — 12 years ago

Mitchella Winery

Paso Robles Petite Sirah 2009

Jesse Doebereiner

9.7

Good. Expensive stolen — 13 years ago

Babcock

Identity Crisis Grenache Rosé

Nate Axline

9.0

Yes you're reading that correctly and yes that's the wine at the bottom. Grenache straight to press and full malo. Great fruit, great structure and acid. Best Identity Crisis yet! — 10 years ago