Becky Bilby

9.1

Excellent Merlot - full of flavor — 10 years ago

Stacey Jaros

9.1

Do not be afraid. This stuff is delicious. — 10 years ago

Jake Perez

9.1

Starting to show its age/rusty edge, but a wonderful value for such high quality Napa wine. I wish I had more on the cellar. — 10 years ago

Adam Baker

9.1

Very good rully. At rusty's with Rusty, Audrey, and Elissa. Pre dinner. — 11 years ago

with Elissa

Nic Vascocu

9.7

Rusty color. Slight oxidation. Solid fruit and acid. Drinks light like a white but has notes of light reds like gamay or Pinot. Classic bressan. Weird and delicious. — 12 years ago

Stacey Jaros

9.7

This wine is very delicious. — 12 years ago

Steve Matthiasson

Owner/Winemaker Matthiasson Wines

10

No question this vintage has gotten a little funky, but it fills me with joy to drink a wine like this from California soil. Cranberries, rusty iron, cinnamon, redwood bark, tangy and easy...this wine is screaming out that we're finally a wine region with cool shit to discover. — 13 years ago

Isabelle Parenti

9.1

Not like most Chardonnays, very good! Sweet and crisp — 10 years ago

with David and Nancy

Manou Chahmirzadi

8.9

Nice body with a little spice and full rusty flavor on finish — 10 years ago

Richard Lewis

9.3

This looked dead - muddy and rusty...but totally different on the palate. Bright red currants, so amazing, and softened nicely the longer it was open... — 10 years ago

with Lynne

Sarah Marie

9.6

In between a porter and a brown ale. Smells sweet and very easy to drink. Smooth and tasteful. — 11 years ago

Ned Clark

9.4

A bit rusty when first opened but an hour later it was magic — 12 years ago

Antoine Pin

Wine Buyer Kroger/QFC

9.1

One of my favorite Pinot towns. Masculin styled. Big cassis, rusty nail notes. — 12 years ago

Lori K

9.3

This is an exceptional Merlot and a great value. Tasted against the Knarley Head and Menage a Trois Merlots and it was every bit as good as they were. All three showed well, but based on price the Mut Lynch is a big, rich winner! — 10 years ago

James Lago

9.6

Perfection. — 10 years ago

Christanna Honer

9.0

Killer value, a Lalande de pomerol w some depth- initial nose of stewed cherry and lead pencil evolved into dried lavender, Chai tea, and bitter cacao nibs with a rusty iron background to it. Silky smooth texture. — 11 years ago

Katie Winter

9.1

Light rusty garnet colored, very clear. The scent was minerals and almost a little grassy. Compelling to drink. Medium finish, soft tannins, good acidity, red cherries, concrete, lots of tasty minerals. Paired really well with spicy red pasta sauce. — 11 years ago

Christopher Parks

Sommelier Per Diem Restaurant

10

Barrel Aged Gin from Blade! — 12 years ago

Kristine Williams

9.1

Bought at barrel tasting weekend. Worth the wait! — 12 years ago

Agustin Palma

9.4

Rusty pelican — 13 years ago